WHITE TEARS by Hari Kunzru
Kirkus Star


Email this review


Record collecting turns dangerous in a smart, time-bending tale about cultural appropriation.

Seth, who narrates most of Kunzru’s fifth novel (Gods Without Men, 2012, etc.), is obsessed with sound, making field recordings of his travels around Manhattan. Carter, his old college buddy and scion of a wealthy family, is similarly obsessed with old blues 78s. Together, they’re an up-and-coming production team that works with white rappers and rock bands looking to make their music sound antique and “authentic.” They’re so good at it that, as a prank, they take Seth’s recording of a Washington Square denizen singing a mordant blues song, use modern tools to faux age it, attribute it to the made-up name Charlie Shaw, and upload it, whereupon online vintage-blues fans go bonkers. Kunzru signals early on that Seth and Carter are playing with fire, from Seth’s hubristic suggestion that his blues knowledge is a passkey to blackness to Carter’s exclusionary and officious family, which made its fortune in private prisons. But Kunzru attacks the racism the two represent indirectly and with some interesting rhetorical twists. Carter is mysteriously beaten into a coma in the Bronx, and once Seth begins an investigation with another collector and Carter’s sister, the narrative begins to deliberately decouple from logic—suggesting, for instance, that a real Charlie Shaw recorded the fake song Seth and Carter created. This weirdness reads subtly at first—a record skipping a groove, a playback glitch—but in time commands the narrative, allowing Kunzru to set the deadly mistreatment of blacks in the Jim Crow South against the hipster presumptions of whites now. Kunzru has done his homework on racial history and white privilege, but the novel is also lifted on his sharp descriptions of music, which he makes so concrete and delectable you understand why his misguided, ill-fated heroes fall so hard for it.

A well-turned and innovative tale that cannily connects old-time blues and modern-day minstrelsy.

Pub Date: March 14th, 2017
ISBN: 978-0-451-49369-9
Page count: 304pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Dec. 15th, 2016


ChildrenWALK WITH ME by Jairo Buitrago
by Jairo Buitrago
ChildrenME TALL, YOU SMALL by Lilli  L'Arronge
by Lilli L'Arronge
ChildrenBRONZE AND SUNFLOWER by Cao Wenxuan
by Cao Wenxuan
ChildrenIT ALL COMES DOWN TO THIS by Karen English
by Karen English
ChildrenTHE MARROW THIEVES by Cherie  Dimaline
by Cherie Dimaline


NonfictionTWICE UPON A TIME by Hari Kunzru
by Hari Kunzru
FictionGODS WITHOUT MEN by Hari Kunzru
by Hari Kunzru
FictionMY REVOLUTIONS by Hari Kunzru
by Hari Kunzru


NonfictionDO NOT SELL AT ANY PRICE by Amanda Petrusich
by Amanda Petrusich
NonfictionDARKEST AMERICA by Yuval Taylor
by Yuval Taylor
NonfictionWHERE DEAD VOICES GATHER by Nick Tosches
by Nick Tosches