HAMILTON'S CHOICE

by Jack Casey ‧ RELEASE DATE: Jan. 21, 2020

A historical novel about the emotional and political events that led up to the famous duel between Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr.

It’s 1801, and Hamilton’s eldest son, Philip, is in the streets of Manhattan, celebrating the inaugural Independence Day under Thomas Jefferson’s administration, when he hears George Eacker besmirch his father, calling him a traitor. Young and focused almost singularly on the concept of honor, Philip is unwilling to let go of the insult. He challenges Eacker to a duel, careful to keep the news from his parents. However, when Hamilton learns of his son’s plans, he and Philip debate the merits of “delope”— throwing away one’s shot. Philip is unwilling to do this, so Hamilton suggests that he shoot, but not kill, Eacker, which will allow Philip to retain his honor. Their plan goes awry, however, resulting in a heart-wrenching fatality. This loss leads Hamilton to carry guilt, as well as the secret of his prior knowledge of Philip’s duel, for the rest of his life. Meanwhile, Burr, Jefferson’s vice president, learns that he will not be on the ballot for Jefferson’s second term. He agrees to support a Federalist plot to have New England secede from the Union if he’s elected governor of New York and subsequently named president of the new confederacy. With support from the Federalists and his connections to the corrupt Tammany Hall, Burr feels his political star rising once again. Now in retirement, Hamilton learns of this plan, which he believes to be treasonous. He hops back into the fray of the political world to stop his fellow Federalists and do his best to block Burr from becoming governor.

Casey, author of Kateri (2012), has an exciting command of language. His skill is particularly evident in the chapters that focus on Burr’s escaping debtors and mingling with women at parties. As a character, Burr is truly alive; readers can sense the charm that he might have exuded in real life. The author’s study of him, including his depictions of his discussions with Hamilton and his letters with his daughter, Theodosia, paint the vice president as not merely a villain in a tragedy, but rather a complex, flawed man whose political aspirations lead to questionable actions. Eliza, Hamilton’s wife, is another strong character; over the course of the book, Casey deftly examines the frustrating reality of being the spouse of a politician, as when Eliza criticizes the actions of the men in her life: “Men lie, Angelica. They all lie. They treat us like fools. We bear their babies and keep their homes and comfort and console them….And they blunder on…without a thought about our well-being or our feelings.” The passages focusing on Hamilton are a bit slow at times; however, the story picks up when necessary, and these sections effectively highlight how the former Treasury secretary is often torn between his love for his family and his commitment to his country.

A vivid portrayal of Hamilton and those who lived in his influential sphere.

Pub Date: Jan. 21, 2020

ISBN: 978-1-73436-669-3

Page Count: 356

Publisher: Diamonds Big as Radishes LLC

Review Posted Online: April 17, 2020

Review Program: Kirkus Indie

Categories: HISTORICAL FICTION