THE SHADOWS by Jacqueline West

THE SHADOWS

The Books of Elsewhere, Volume 1
by & illustrated by
Age Range: 10 - 12
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Preoccupied parents, a solitary young girl, talking cats—sound familiar? Unfortunately for debut author West, not only has this been done before, it’s been done better. Still, the premise is intriguing. Magical spectacles enable the wearer to enter the worlds captured in paintings created by an evil, long-dead wizard. “Captured” isn’t just a figure of speech: At least one young boy has been turned into a painted replica of himself. Another painting, that of the wizard’s (also dead) granddaughter, comes creepily to life. In general, though, the action is sluggish and the ominous atmosphere contrived. Characterization is skimpy at best. Olive’s parents adore math. Olive doesn’t. The cats are pompous, imaginative and martial, respectively. Ironically enough, it’s not just the supernatural effects that fail to convince. Would parents, even those utterly obsessed with their own intelligence and interests, really leave their 11-year-old home alone overnight? The fact that they do precipitates Olive’s final confrontation with the wicked wizard. Unfortunately readers probably won’t care much about who wins nor about the possibility of volume two. (Fantasy. 10-12)

Pub Date: June 1st, 2010
ISBN: 978-0-8037-3440-1
Page count: 256pp
Publisher: Dial
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15th, 2010




2010 CYBILS AWARD WINNERS:

ChildrenTHE STRANGE CASE OF ORIGAMI YODA by Tom Angleberger
by Tom Angleberger
ChildrenSPLIT by Swati Avasthi
by Swati Avasthi
ChildrenZAPATO POWER by Jacqueline Jules
by Jacqueline Jules
ChildrenTHE SECRET OF THE YELLOW DEATH by Suzanne Jurmain
by Suzanne Jurmain
ChildrenTHE EXTRAORDINARY MARK TWAIN by Barbara Kerley
by Barbara Kerley

MORE BY JACQUELINE WEST

ChildrenDIGGING UP DANGER by Jacqueline West
by Jacqueline West
ChildrenTHE COLLECTORS by Jacqueline West
by Jacqueline West
ChildrenDREAMERS OFTEN LIE by Jacqueline West
by Jacqueline West

MORE BY POLY BERNATENE

ChildrenI'M A GNOME! by Jessica Peill-Meininghaus
by Jessica Peill-Meininghaus
ChildrenTHE BOOKSHOP GIRL by Sylvia Bishop
by Sylvia Bishop
ChildrenSKYFISHING by Gideon Sterer
by Gideon Sterer

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenMERCY by Sarah L. Thomson
by Sarah L. Thomson
ChildrenTHE GRAVE KEEPERS by Elizabeth Byrne
by Elizabeth Byrne
ChildrenDANGER! TIGER CROSSING by Lin Oliver
by Lin Oliver