WILLIE MAYS by James S. Hirsch

WILLIE MAYS

The Life, the Legend

KIRKUS REVIEW

An admiring—at times even worshipful—portrait of one of baseball's greatest players, whose on-field exploits were astonishing but whose inner life remains largely hidden.

On the first page, former New York Times and Wall Street Journal reporter Hirsch (Cheating Destiny: Living with Diabetes, America's Biggest Epidemic, 2006, etc.)—who wrote a bestselling biography of boxer Rubin Carter (Hurricane, 2000)—compares the body of Willie Mays to “Michelangelo's finest work” and notes later that his “best catches seemed to be guided by some divine spirit.” Fans of Mays will no doubt applaud such effusions, but they signal that celebration is higher on the author's agenda than critical analysis. Mays's Hall of Fame career was indeed marvelous. Born in Birmingham, Ala., in 1931, he endured the Jim Crow South, thrived on the baseball field and then left for greener outfields. Hirsch discusses how he learned baseball's fundamentals from his father, mastered his unique “basket catch” (in the Army), got the nickname “Say Hey Kid,” rocketed through the minors, debuted with the New York Giants in 1951 and quickly became baseball's dominant star and its most exciting player—for decades (he played into his 40s, ending his career with the Mets). The author attends well to those most celebrated Willie moments: “The Throw,” “The Catch,” the four-homer day, the bare-handed catches, the daring base running, the dramatic hits, the peacemaking during base-brawls. But he also portrays a man who had difficulty with personal relationships and with intimacy—a failed first marriage, a need for pampering managers. Other black athletes—most notably Jackie Robinson—chided Mays for lassitude during the civil-rights movement, and others wondered why he did not support Curt Flood's lawsuit. But Hirsch remains an apologist, and Mays's 40 years of retirement are relegated to a 30-page epilogue.

Well-researched and fluid, but tendentious and tunnel-visioned.

Pub Date: Feb. 9th, 2010
ISBN: 978-1-4165-4790-7
Page count: 624pp
Publisher: Scribner
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 15th, 2009




THE “WE’RE NOT DRINKING THE KOOL-AID” LIST OF 2010 (ACCLAIMED BOOKS—OR BOOKS BY ACCLAIMED AUTHORS—THAT DIDN’T LIVE UP TO OUR EXPECTATIONS):

Fiction BY NIGHTFALL by Michael Cunningham
by Michael Cunningham
Nonfiction ABOUT A MOUNTAIN by John D’Agata
by John D’Agata
Fiction IMPERIAL BEDROOMS by Bret Easton Ellis
by Bret Easton Ellis
Fiction FREEDOM by Jonathan Franzen
by Jonathan Franzen

MORE BY JAMES S. HIRSCH

NonfictionWALK IN THEIR SHOES by Jim Ziolkowski
by Jim Ziolkowski
NonfictionCHEATING DESTINY by James S. Hirsch
by James S. Hirsch
NonfictionRIOT AND REMEMBRANCE by James S. Hirsch
by James S. Hirsch

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionSATCHEL by Larry Tye
by Larry Tye
NonfictionTHE SOUL OF BASEBALL by Joe Posnanski
by Joe Posnanski
NonfictionTHE LAST HERO by Howard Bryant
by Howard Bryant