GRUMBLES FROM THE TOWN by Jane Yolen

GRUMBLES FROM THE TOWN

Mother-Goose Voices with a Twist
Age Range: 5 - 9
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

This quirky Mother Goose book turns convention on its head.

Each of the 14 selections contemporizes a traditional rhyme and pairs it with a rebuttal or an aside by a grumpy protagonist. The vegetarian princess in “Sing a Song of Sixpence” waxes poetic about freeing blackbirds while (inexplicably) dealing with “four-and-twenty cantaloupes / stashed inside my jeans.” Her grumpy maid, however, launches into an unwieldy tirade about avian-infested pies. “A bloke poked his head out the window. / King wants another pie! he cried. / I mumbled a few choice words, I did. / Who, I ask you, in their right mind / bakes pies of birds?” The double-page format facilitates the flow from reworked verse to denouement. Spoon is pleased with her rescue from fiddling cats and moon-leaping cows, and Plum rants against Jack Horner's skewering thumb. Matteson’s acrylic-and–colored-pencil illustrations on wood board smoothly incorporate racial diversity; Jack Horner is black, and King Cole and his daughter have light-brown skin and kinky hair. The artwork is lively and fanciful—Humpty rides a skateboard, and Miss Muffet’s plotting spider strums a banjo. However, the collection is in want of an audience. Rather than poems clearly written for children, this latest Yolen/Dotlich collaboration (Grumbles from the Forest, 2013) comes across as a creative-writing exercise. The original nursery rhymes and historical notes are appended (to the detriment of the new rhymes).

An inventive miss. (Picture book. 5-9)

Pub Date: Sept. 13th, 2016
ISBN: 978-1-59078-922-3
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Calkins Creek/Boyds Mills
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1st, 2016




MORE BY JANE YOLEN

ChildrenTHUNDER UNDERGROUND by Jane Yolen
by Jane Yolen
ChildrenTHE SEELIE KING'S WAR by Jane Yolen
by Jane Yolen

MORE BY REBECCA KAI DOTLICH

ChildrenTHE KNOWING BOOK by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
ChildrenRACE CAR COUNT by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
ChildrenONE DAY, THE END. by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
by Rebecca Kai Dotlich

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenMONSTER GOOSE by Judy Sierra
by Judy Sierra
ChildrenTHE COW TRIPPED OVER THE MOON by Jeanne Willis
by Jeanne Willis