CULTURES OF WAR by John W. Dower
Kirkus Star

CULTURES OF WAR

Pearl Harbor / Hiroshima / 9-11 / Iraq

KIRKUS REVIEW

Pulitzer Prize– and National Book Award–winning historian Dower (Embracing Defeat: Japan in the Wake of World War II, 1999, etc.) draws astute ironies between Pearl Harbor and 9/11 in terms of the overweening arrogance of military superpowers.

The author moves back and forth between these two definitive eras in history, providing a brilliant examination of the willful self-delusion and selective reasoning involved in the highest levels of decision making—from Japan’s spectacularly ill-advised bombing of Pearl Harbor to the Bush Administration’s bundling of “weapons of mass destruction” and Osama bin Laden as justification for invasion of Iraq. Dower is intensely interested in the language of war, specifically the “code” words that prime the propaganda pump—e.g., “infamy,” as used to ignite public opinion against the enemy by both presidents Roosevelt and Bush; “ground zero,” evoked after the atomic bombs dropped on Japan and then after 9/11, underscoring in both incidences the terrible momentum of modern weaponry and the deliberate targeting of noncombatants; and “occupying power,” a term that morphed from carrying a benevolent connotation in postwar Japan to the malevolent quagmire that ensued in Iraq. The author traces the “groupthink” mentality through the faulty, blinkered rationale by the Japanese warlords as well as the Islamists and the Americans. Most presciently, Dower looks at America’s creation of what the late Benazir Bhutto called a “Frankenstein’s monster” in the Middle East—the sanctimonious preaching of democracy and justice on one hand, and the practice of supporting tyrannical regimes and military intervention on the other. The myth of American innocence and victimization (“Pearl Harbor,” “9/11”) is shattered by the baleful effects of terror bombing, torture (Abu Ghraib) and racism—what Dower calls a “profound failure of imagination” in thinking that the “little yellow men” and the “little Muslim sons-of-bitches” could execute such ingenious attacks.

An unrelenting, incisive, masterly comparative study.

Pub Date: Sept. 7th, 2010
ISBN: 978-0-393-06150-5
Page count: 608pp
Publisher: Norton
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2010




2010 NATIONAL BOOK AWARD FINALISTS:

Fiction PARROT AND OLIVIER IN AMERICA by Peter Carey
by Peter Carey
Fiction LORD OF MISRULE by Jaimy Gordon
by Jaimy Gordon
Fiction GREAT HOUSE by Nicole Krauss
by Nicole Krauss
Fiction SO MUCH FOR THAT by Lionel Shriver
by Lionel Shriver

MORE BY JOHN W. DOWER

NonfictionWAYS OF FORGETTING, WAYS OF REMEMBERING by John W. Dower
by John W. Dower
NonfictionEMBRACING DEFEAT by John W. Dower
by John W. Dower
NonfictionJAPAN IN WAR AND PEACE by John W. Dower
by John W. Dower

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionDREAMING WAR by Gore Vidal
by Gore Vidal
NonfictionBENDING ADVERSITY by David Pilling
by David Pilling
NonfictionA RENEGADE HISTORY OF THE UNITED STATES by Thaddeus Russell
by Thaddeus Russell