BRIAR AND ROSE AND JACK by Katherine Coville

BRIAR AND ROSE AND JACK

Age Range: 9 - 11
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Sleeping Beauty meets Jack the Giant-Killer in this retelling.

Lady Briar and Princess Rose are twins—but neither one knows this. When they were born—Rose with a flawless face and Briar with a protruding brow and drooping eyelid—the horrified king declared he could not raise such an ugly child as his heir. Briar, raised as the orphan of a minor noble, grows up best friends with Rose, though most other children and adults at court treat her with cruelty for her ugliness. Neither girl knows of the fairies who attended their christening and gave them a smattering of blessings, nor do they know of the wicked fairy who laid a curse that will take effect on their 16th birthday. As the girls grow, they become friends with Jack, a devastatingly poor villager. Together they form a secret society: the Giant Killers! The Giant Killers know that when they’re big enough, they’ll defeat the wicked giant who is always stealing their tiny kingdom’s food and treasure, leaving the kingdom poor and the villagers starving. The two intertwined fairy tales, with white characters in a Christian, medieval Europe–esque setting, proceed as expected, complicated only by the presence of Briar. Both plotting and writing feel underdone, with arbitrary plot elements and character swings driving events.

Though a pleasant tale of friendship, the melding of the two well-known stories enriches neither. (Fantasy. 9-11)

Pub Date: June 11th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-328-95005-5
Page count: 368pp
Publisher: Clarion
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 1st, 2019




MORE BY KATHERINE COVILLE

ChildrenIVY by Katherine Coville
by Katherine Coville
ChildrenTHE COTTAGE IN THE WOODS by Katherine Coville
by Katherine Coville
ChildrenMOONGOBBLE AND ME by Bruce Coville
by Bruce Coville

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenA MONSTER LIKE ME by Wendy S. Swore
by Wendy S. Swore
ChildrenCOGHEART by Peter Bunzl
by Peter Bunzl
ChildrenMIGHTY JACK by Ben Hatke
by Ben Hatke