FALLINGWATER by Marc Harshman

FALLINGWATER

Age Range: 6 - 9
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Late in his career, architect Frank Lloyd Wright designed one of the world’s most famous houses.

In 1934, Pittsburgh retail magnate Edgar Kaufmann hired Wright to build a house near the waterfalls of Bear Run, Pennsylvania. This book traces Wright’s steps through planning, construction, and successful completion of the unusual house nestled in a hillside. The illustrations echo the Japanese print style that inspired Wright’s design in spreads paced to underscore the tranquil setting. One vertical double-page spread emphasizes the height of the house jutting over the waterfalls. The book’s effectiveness, however, is marred by inconsistencies in text and illustration that seem to be a result of an attempt to appeal to both younger and older children. Languid prose alternates with short, choppy sentences throughout. For instance, the narrative recounts Wright’s dreams in stately free verse: “In dreaming this house he will use everything / he has ever seen: stone walls from Wisconsin, / sand and adobe from the Southwest, / towers and trellises from Italy.” His client’s desire for speed comes in jarringly clipped sentences: “Mr. Kaufmann calls. He is in Wisconsin. / He is coming to visit. / He wants to see the plans. / He will arrive in two hours. / He is coming to see his new house!” This, coupled with the flat, cartoonish depiction of some characters (mostly though not exclusively white), detracts from an otherwise pleasant book.

Will provide some inspiration for budding architects. (authors’ note, artist’s note, bibliography, notes) (Informational picture book. 6-9)

Pub Date: Oct. 17th, 2017
ISBN: 978-1-59643-718-0
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Roaring Brook
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 15th, 2017




MORE BY MARC HARSHMAN

ChildrenONE BIG FAMILY by Marc Harshman
by Marc Harshman
ChildrenONLY ONE NEIGHBORHOOD by Marc Harshman
by Marc Harshman
ChildrenUNCLE JAMES by Marc Harshman
by Marc Harshman

MORE BY ANNA EGAN SMUCKER

ChildrenBROTHER GIOVANNI'S LITTLE REWARD by Anna Egan Smucker
by Anna Egan Smucker
ChildrenGOLDEN DELICIOUS by Anna Egan Smucker
by Anna Egan Smucker

MORE BY LEUYEN PHAM

ChildrenSHEEP 101 by Richard T. Morris
by Richard T. Morris
ChildrenTHE TWELVE DAYS OF CHRISTMAS by LeUyen  Pham
by LeUyen Pham
ChildrenBO AT BALLARD CREEK by Kirkpatrick Hill
by Kirkpatrick Hill
ChildrenALVIN HO by Lenore Look
by Lenore Look

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTHE SHAPE OF THE WORLD by K.L. Going
by K.L. Going
ChildrenTHE WORLD IS NOT A RECTANGLE by Jeanette Winter
by Jeanette Winter