WHO'D BELIEVE JOHN COLTER? by Mary Blount Christian


Age Range: 7 - 11
Email this review


 Catalogued by LC as nonfiction and equipped with a lengthy source list, a lively account of one of Lewis and Clark's men: John Colter (1775?-1813), who's depicted here as a witty daredevil frontiersman so noted for tall tales that people found it hard to credit his reports of his considerable real exploits- -e.g., some bold escapes from the Blackfeet and the discovery of some of the West's boiling mudholes and geysers. Christian's narrative, however, larded as it is with clearly made-up dialogue and descriptions (``John took a deep breath and leaned back, crossing his arms over his chest in satisfaction''), reads like fiction; in the absence of qualifiers like ``must have,'' or ``perhaps,'' a scrupulous explanatory note would have been a real plus. Still, the author gives a more vividly detailed look at the Lewis and Clark expedition than the Roops offer in their excerpts of the explorers' own words (below), while Kubinyi's delicately crosshatched full-page drawings, recalling 19th-century engravings, contribute nicely to an inviting format. Not scholarly, but fun. (Biography. 7-11)

Pub Date: May 31st, 1993
ISBN: 0-02-718477-3
Page count: 64pp
Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1st, 1993


ChildrenTIME TO BUILD by Kate Riggs
by Kate Riggs
ChildrenCAT MUMMIES by Kelly Trumble
by Kelly Trumble
ChildrenTHE WIZARD IN THE TREE by Lloyd Alexander
by Lloyd Alexander