THE MARE by Mary Gaitskill
Kirkus Star


Email this review


A young Dominican girl from the mean streets of Brooklyn forges a relationship with a white woman living in a bucolic upstate town and learns to love horses and respect herself.

Eleven-year-old Velvet has a soft name, but there’s nothing even remotely plush about her life in a rough part of Crown Heights, Brooklyn. Abused (mostly, but not only, verbally) by her mother, a tough immigrant, Velvet has little to call her own (she keeps her treasured objects—a shell, a dried sea horse, a broken keychain doll—in an old cotton-ball box in the back of a closet) and few friends, almost no one she can trust. Velvet’s mother clearly prefers her 6-year-old son, Dante, singing him to sleep at night with her back to Velvet in the family’s shared bed. Instead of comfort and cuddles, Velvet gets the message that she’s “no good”—not that it’s really her fault; it’s just that her blood is bad. While Velvet craves her mother’s love and attention, Ginger, a 47-year-old sometime artist recovering from alcoholism and drug abuse, an abusive relationship, and the death of her troubled sister, finds herself yearning for a child. Now living a comfortable life in upstate New York with Paul, her college-professor husband, Ginger has decided to “test the waters” of adoption by hosting a Fresh Air Fund kid for a couple of weeks, a commitment that stretches far longer and deeper. That’s how Velvet and Ginger meet, and it's also how Velvet meets a mistrustful and mistreated horse at the stable next door to Ginger's house, the horse the others call “Fugly Girl” and she renames “Fiery Girl,” whom she will tame and train, and who will do the same for her. Alternating primarily between Velvet's and Ginger’s perspectives, with occasional observations from other characters, National Book Award finalist Gaitskill (Veronica, 2005, etc.) takes a premise that could have been preachy, sentimental, or simplistic—juxtaposing urban and rural, rich and poor, young and old, brown and white—and makes it candid and emotionally complex, spare, real, and deeply affecting.

Gaitskill explores the complexities of love (mares, meres…) to bring us a novel that gallops along like a bracing bareback ride on a powerful thoroughbred.

Pub Date: Nov. 3rd, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-307-37974-0
Page count: 464pp
Publisher: Pantheon
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1st, 2015


FictionTHE MARE by Mary Gaitskill
by Mary Gaitskill
FictionCITY ON FIRE by Garth Risk Hallberg
by Garth Risk Hallberg
FictionDELICIOUS FOODS by James Hannaham
by James Hannaham
FictionTHE INCARNATIONS by Susan Barker
by Susan Barker


FictionDON’T CRY by Mary Gaitskill
by Mary Gaitskill
FictionBEST NEW AMERICAN VOICES 2009 by Mary Gaitskill
by Mary Gaitskill
FictionVERONICA by Mary Gaitskill
by Mary Gaitskill


FictionBARBARA THE SLUT by Lauren Holmes
by Lauren Holmes
FictionBARK by Lorrie Moore
by Lorrie Moore
FictionAMERICAN HOUSEWIFE by Helen Ellis
by Helen Ellis