WE ARE NOT OURSELVES by Matthew Thomas

WE ARE NOT OURSELVES

KIRKUS REVIEW

An Irish-American family in New York City pursues simple dreams in a long and only partially satisfying first novel.

Thomas' debut opens promisingly with the outsize character of Big Mike Tumulty, an Irish immigrant and bar-stool sage possessed of “a terrible charisma.” The humor and brisk pace of this well-drawn section too rarely recur in the many dry, dour pages that follow. Mike’s daughter and the book’s heroine, Eileen, arrives in 1941 and grows up in a household where affection and money are scarce. She pursues a nursing career, marries a teacher named Ed Leary and has a son, Connell. Eileen is driven to improve their housing, from rented rooms in a multifamily Queens home to owning that home and finally the big move to the costly suburb of Bronxville. Only a few pages later, at the book’s midpoint, they learn that Ed, at 51, has early-onset Alzheimer’s, “the most virulent kind….It dismantles motor functions and speech as it erases the memory.” Thomas, who has relied to this point on thinly linked vignettes, is most effective in the sustained picture of Ed’s terrible decline and Eileen’s fierce struggle to maintain his dignity and her control. And a story almost painfully confined to the family trio now acquires a couple of colorful characters in a healer who speaks through the spirit Vywamus and a hired man named Sergei who offers strength and the chance of new passion.

Despite its epic size and aspirations, the novel is underpopulated and often underwritten, a quality that does make its richer moments stand out while stoking the appetite for more of those in fewer pages.

Pub Date: Sept. 2nd, 2014
ISBN: 978-1-4767-5666-0
Page count: 640pp
Publisher: Simon & Schuster
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 15th, 2014




OUR CRITICS' TAKES ON MORE BESTSELLERS

See full list >
Cover art for THE WHITES
VERDICT:
BUY IT
Cover art for THE DUFF
VERDICT:
BUY IT
Cover art for THE ONLY GAME
VERDICT:
BORROW IT
Cover art for H IS FOR HAWK
VERDICT:
BUY IT

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

FictionTRINITY by Leon Uris
by Leon Uris
FictionACADEMY STREET by Mary Costello
by Mary Costello
NonfictionANGELA'S ASHES by Frank McCourt
by Frank McCourt