ASIA'S CAULDRON by Robert D. Kaplan


The South China Sea and the End of a Stable Pacific
Email this review


A foreign policy expert looks at the major players in the Southeast Asia Pacific Rim and their nervous watching of what China will do.

Atlantic foreign correspondent Kaplan (The Revenge of Geography: What the Map Tells Us About Coming Conflicts and the Battle Against Fate, 2012, etc.) frequently refers to geography as key in determining developments in the countries he addresses with his keen insight: namely, Vietnam, Malaysia, Singapore, the Philippines, Taiwan and China. Indeed, these—save the Philippines, still mired in American colonial dependency—have evolved into post–Cold War economic dynamos, with varying blends of democracy and authoritarianism. Thus, for the first time, they can “flex their muscles at sea” by making territorial claims against each other regarding the rich oil and natural gas reserves harbored among the straits and the hundreds of islands scattered throughout the area. Kaplan compares China’s position amid the South China Sea grouping as akin to America’s “practically sovereign” regard of the Greater Caribbean—that is, if China were finally to “Finlandize” Taiwan and replace the U.S. Navy’s domination in the area. As the U.S. downgrades its naval presence and continues to be distracted by wars in Afghanistan and elsewhere, China is ramping up its military presence. Although Kaplan claims there is no “moral fury” roiling the area, his discrete breakdown of each country delineates many troubling authoritarian histories, with a blithe dismissal of democratic tenets. For example, Kaplan acknowledges the ends-justifies-the-means approach of China’s Deng Xiaoping and Singapore’s Lee Kuan Yew, who effected economic miracles while ruling with an iron grip. The author’s considerations of jihadist insurgent threats in Indonesia and elsewhere seem tepid.

An up-and-down examination in which the author claims that the future of the Pacific Rim will be decided not by what China does but by what America does.

Pub Date: March 25th, 2014
ISBN: 978-0-8129-9432-2
Page count: 256pp
Publisher: Random House
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1st, 2014


NonfictionTHE RETURN OF MARCO POLO'S WORLD by Robert D. Kaplan
by Robert D. Kaplan
NonfictionEARNING THE ROCKIES by Robert D. Kaplan
by Robert D. Kaplan
NonfictionIN EUROPE'S SHADOW by Robert D. Kaplan
by Robert D. Kaplan


NonfictionINDONESIA by Geoff Simons
by Geoff Simons
NonfictionTHE RETURN OF MARCO POLO'S WORLD by Robert D. Kaplan
by Robert D. Kaplan
NonfictionEASTERNIZATION by Gideon Rachman
by Gideon Rachman