CULTURE OF COMPLAINT by Robert Hughes

CULTURE OF COMPLAINT

The Fraying of America

KIRKUS REVIEW

 It's hard not to be stirred up and entertained by the three jeremiad-essays Hughes (Barcelona, 1992, etc.) offers here. He goes scatter-shooting at cows with very broad sides: “the American talent for the twin fetishes of victimhood and redemption”; the PC academy (“ ‘The Canon,’ that oppressive Big Bertha whose muzzle is trained...at the black, the gay, and the female. The Canon, we're told, is a list of books by dead Europeans—Shakespeare and Dante and Tolstoy...you know them, the pale patriarchal penis people”); postmodern architects (“the pediment-quoting Ralph Laurens of their profession”); Jean-Michel Basquiat (“the black Chatterton of the 80's”). Hughes deplores the “multi-culti” scam of a cultural establishment unwilling to stand up to the Jesse Helms-types and thus retreating into an homogenization that doles out quality to all so that none will rise too high to be chopped down. But real European- or Australian-style multiculturalism, he argues, is of great benefit—a haunting of one culture by another, an enrichening. So far so good (if glitzy: for Time's art-critic, there's no idea whose subtlety can't be sacrificed for a clever line). But the swaggering postures Hughes assumes all over the room are convincing only in the brightest-lit corners. He does a little historical background for his best point--that art for Americans has always been a therapeutic activity—but elsewhere hardly a background is shaded in. The problematics behind our melding of cultures, behind a moral issue such as abortion, or underlying formalism and shock-aesthetics—these Hughes avoids drilling into deeply. Mostly, it seems, he's writing to the small, disenchanted section of the same go-go cultural guild he bewails; in such tight company, he has to do little more than press journalistic hot buttons cleverly. Not since John Gardner's On Moral Fiction (1978) have we had such a pellet-gun shower of right-wing leftism, back-to-basics positivism--and like Gardner's, it settles down more as vanitas than veritas.

Pub Date: April 1st, 1993
ISBN: 0-19-507676-1
Page count: 210pp
Publisher: Oxford Univ.
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 1st, 1993




ROBERT HUGHES, 1938-2012:

Nonfiction A JERK ON ONE END by Robert Hughes
by Robert Hughes
Nonfiction AMERICAN VISIONS by Robert Hughes
by Robert Hughes
Nonfiction CULTURE OF COMPLAINT by Robert Hughes
by Robert Hughes
Nonfiction BARCELONA by Robert Hughes
by Robert Hughes

MORE BY ROBERT HUGHES

NonfictionROME by Robert Hughes
by Robert Hughes
NonfictionTHINGS I DIDN’T KNOW by Robert Hughes
by Robert Hughes
NonfictionGOYA by Robert Hughes
by Robert Hughes