FAMILY MATTERS by Rohinton Mistry
Kirkus Star


Email this review


A Dickensian sense of the interconnections of place, character, and fate and a powerful rendering of the experience and consequences of aging and bodily decay—such are the great strengths of this absorbing third novel from the Indian-born Canadian resident (A Fine Balance, 1996, etc.).

Mistry is a deservedly much-honored writer who has won Canada’s Governor General’s Award and the Commonwealth Writers Prize. And he achieves a real triumph with this story’s wonderful protagonist: 79-year-old retired professor Nariman Vakeel, whom we meet in the lavish Bombay apartment (in a building called “Chateau Felicity”) he shares with his intemperate stepdaughter Coomy and her passive brother Jal. In lengthy flashbacks, Nariman recalls the great mistake of his earlier years: forsaking the Catholic woman he loved, and yielding to parental pressure to marry the Parsi widow who meant nothing to him—as her children (Coomy and Jal) have long known. When Nariman breaks an ankle, his stepchildren (a virtual Goneril and Regan) send him to live with the family of his natural daughter, Roxana Chenoy, in a crowded, filthy tenement—where Nariman slides into helplessness, and Roxana patiently bears this new burden. The King Lear–derived plot is handled beautifully (especially whenever Mistry enters Nariman’s consciousness). But efforts to broaden the story’s scope seem, by comparison, forced—especially in sequences detailing the desperate grasp for upward mobility made by Roxana’s husband Yezad, whose yearnings for a better life for his family propel him toward gambling and crime (a development ironically echoed by the schoolboy “career” of manipulative exploitation pursued by the Chenoys’ elder son Jehangir).

Nevertheless, a powerfully lurid picture of Bombay’s multiplicity, energy, and squalor is built up with masterly skill. And the characters of Nariman and the Gandhi-inspired Roxana (her father’s Cordelia) are not easily forgotten.

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2002
ISBN: 0-375-40373-6
Page count: 448pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2002


FictionBROCADE VALLEY by Wang Anyi
by Wang Anyi
FictionKIERON SMITH, BOY by James Kelman
by James Kelman
FictionOUR KIND OF TRAITOR by John le Carré
by John Le Carré
NonfictionORIGINS by Amin Maalouf
by Amin Maalouf


FictionA FINE BALANCE by Rohinton Mistry
by Rohinton Mistry
FictionSUCH A LONG JOURNEY by Rohinton Mistry
by Rohinton Mistry


FictionA STATE OF FREEDOM by Neel Mukherjee
by Neel Mukherjee
IndieTHE DELHI DECEPTION by Elana Sabharwal
by Elana Sabharwal