THE POND GOD by Samuel Jay Keyser

THE POND GOD

and Other Stories
by & illustrated by
Age Range: 9 - 12
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Original fables in free verse are only varyingly successful, making for a collection that fizzles. Several dozen stories fit on a single page each and tell about “How a Thief Stole the Horizon,” “How the Gods Learned to Wait,” and “How Clouds Came to Be,” etc. Each ends with a moral, and is accompanied by a single-page illustration. These sketchy line drawings are often awkward, and have little child appeal. The stories suffer similarly, borrowing from several traditions while acknowledging none (even if they were “inspired by a Navaho shaman.”) Keyser seems to be trying to create his own mythology, but the stories are amorphous and fail to cohere. Some even contradict others. (In the last five stories the gods “die without a trace,” then are “left behind,” then stay, then “learn to die,” then all lie down which ends “the first universe.”) These flaws undermine Keyser’s occasional insights and lyricism, and make this a disappointing collection. (Folktales. 9-12)

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2003
ISBN: 1-886910-96-0
Page count: 96pp
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Oct. 15th, 2003




MORE BY ROBERT SHETTERLY

ChildrenAMERICANS WHO TELL THE TRUTH by Robert Shetterly
by Robert Shetterly
ChildrenWHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE? by Elizabeth A. Lacey
by Elizabeth A. Lacey
ChildrenMUWIN AND THE MAGIC HARE by Susan Hand--Adapt. Shetterly
by Susan Hand--Adapt. Shetterly