A THIRSTY LAND by Seamus McGraw


The Making of an American Water Crisis
Email this review


A hard look at a hard problem: finding sufficient water to live in a place without much of it.

Texas, writes journalist McGraw (Betting the Farm on a Drought: Stories from the Front Lines of Climate Change, 2015, etc.), sits at the same latitude as the Sahara and has much of that desert region’s aridity—so much so that in any given year, “it is more likely that a significant drought will occur somewhere than it is that the average amount of rain will fall.” If that formulation makes your head hurt, imagine how a Texas farmer or rancher feels, especially given the state’s right-of-capture water law, which essentially says you can extract all the water that sits underneath the land you own, even if that action dries up your neighbor’s well. In one instance, a farmer in arid West Texas is growing rice, knowing that it’s a wetlands crop better suited to the Gulf Coast, to make a point that the system of water rights is irrevocably broken. McGraw traveled the length and breadth of the Lone Star State talking with people whose livelihoods are directly contingent on the flow of water, a problem that will soon confront Americans everywhere given the trends of climate change. In that sense, as so often, Texas is a bellwether. Houston, as he observes, has fine drinking water, but that came about because the formerly poorly used Trinity River, which flows a couple of hundred miles from Dallas southward, was heavily regulated under the terms of a water regime that has been in place since the 1950s and reinforced under the terms of the U.S. Clean Water Act. In our current anti-regulatory climate, the water may get dirtier in the coming years. It’s a wait-and-see thing, in other words, but in the meantime, McGraw’s fine book serves as a useful guide.

Observers of Western waterways will want to have this on their shelves alongside the likes of Marc Reisner and Charles Bowden.

Pub Date: May 9th, 2018
ISBN: 978-1-4773-1031-1
Page count: 300pp
Publisher: Univ. of Texas
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 2018


NonfictionBETTING THE FARM ON A DROUGHT by Seamus McGraw
by Seamus McGraw
NonfictionTHE END OF COUNTRY by Seamus McGraw
by Seamus McGraw


NonfictionCADILLAC DESERT by Marc Reisner
by Marc Reisner
NonfictionDAM NATION by Stephen Grace
by Stephen Grace
NonfictionWATER by Alice Outwater
by Alice Outwater