OUTLAW PLATOON by Sean Parnell


Heroes, Renegades, Infidels, and the Brotherhood of War in Afghanistan
Email this review


Grim, gritty account of infantry combat on the Afghanistan-Pakistan border, from a youthful lieutenant determined to act nobly amid violence and chaos.

In 2006, Parnell was a neophyte Army Airborne Ranger with the storied 10th Mountain Division, assigned as a new platoon leader in Afghanistan, desperate to prove himself: “In combat, men measure up. Or fail. There are no second chances.” This honesty about emotional and sensory aspects of combat drives this narrative more than overt commentary on the Afghanistan mission. As it happened, Parnell received many opportunities to prove himself in battle. The narrative develops around several grueling set pieces, in which Parnell’s platoon was ambushed by an insurgent faction that unexpectedly turned out to be a skilled, disciplined and cold-blooded fighting force, determined to win a propaganda victory by brutalizing an American platoon. These raw, controlled scenes of battle seemingly benefit from the authorial collaboration: Besides being a prolific author of military histories, Bruning (Chasing Shadows: A Special Agent's Lifelong Hunt to Bring a Cold War Assassin to Justice, 2011, etc.) embedded himself with a combat unit in Afghanistan in 2010. The result is a carefully rendered account of Parnell’s tour, with verisimilitude provided by extensive specific details illustrating the sheer complexity of modern combat, as well as the frustrating officer politics on remote bases. Parnell focuses on the experiences of several platoon members, and he writes that it is brotherly love that bonds soldiers in combat, ensuring their survival. He also observes his comrades’ deep ambivalence toward their Pakistani allies and the Afghani people's willingness to reform and defend their society. The book’s main flaw is a repetitiveness that becomes mawkish: Points about the soldiers’ personal burdens and the bond of brotherhood in combat are made so often that they become less rather than more effective. This flaw, however, may not bother the book’s intended audience.

Well-told combat narrative that raises disturbing questions about America’s professionalized military and the post-9/11 objectives with which they’ve been tasked.

Pub Date: March 1st, 2012
ISBN: 978-0-06-206639-8
Page count: 400pp
Publisher: Morrow/HarperCollins
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 1st, 2012


NonfictionTHE LAST FULL MEASURE by Michael Stephenson
by Michael Stephenson
NonfictionINTO DUST AND FIRE by Rachel S. Cox
by Rachel S. Cox
NonfictionDRIFT by Rachel Maddow
by Rachel Maddow
NonfictionTHE TASTE OF WAR by Lizzie Collingham
by Lizzie Collingham


IndieGOLD STAR CHRISTMAS by Edwin C Brannan II
by Edwin C Brannan II
NonfictionHEROES AMONG US by Chuck Larson
by Chuck Larson
NonfictionPUMPKINFLOWERS by Matti Friedman
by Matti Friedman