TIM'S GOODBYE by Steven Salerno


by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 3 - 6
Email this review


How do you let go of a departed pet?

Salerno’s retro caricatures exemplify comforting memorial behaviors. Black crayon is used to form the characters on the sunny yellow pages; a controlled digital palette includes accents of darker yellow, white, and black. Channeling a Bemelmans’ heroine, Margot wears a skirt and an oversized bow in her pageboy. The minimalist garden setting features a chair, four white tulips, and a yellow lump. Thoughtful friends contribute blue balloons and a box. Otto dons his “best hat,” while Melinda plays a “cheerful melody” on her French horn. Buddy the dog is actively present. The lump turns out to be Tim, who, when covered with the flowers and arranged in the box, ascends into the now-blue sky “to a place where he basked in the warm sun and swam in cool waters, forever a happy turtle.” As in Remy Charlip’s and, later, Christian Robinson’s versions of Margaret Wise Brown’s The Dead Bird (1958, 2016), Salerno shows readers how to help a friend mourn a dead animal. Most important, of course, is showing up. Similar to the kites in the aforementioned editions, the balloons add an important buoyancy to the telling, providing a possible entree to matters of the spirit, if readers desire it. The characters are all the yellow of the paper save friend Vincent, who is a darker yellow and has crinkly dark hair.

A succinct text and an uncluttered design provide space to discover and process a loss. (Picture book. 3-6)

Pub Date: April 17th, 2018
ISBN: 978-0-374-30647-2
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1st, 2018


ChildrenTHE CRAYON MAN by Natascha Biebow
by Natascha Biebow
ChildrenWILD HORSE ANNIE by Tracey Fern
by Tracey Fern
ChildrenPASS GO AND COLLECT $200 by Tanya Lee Stone
by Tanya Lee Stone


ChildrenTHE GOODBYE BOOK by Todd Parr
by Todd Parr
ChildrenDUCK, DEATH AND THE TULIP by Wolf Erlbruch
by Wolf Erlbruch
ChildrenTHE PURPLE BALLOON by Chris Raschka
by Chris Raschka