THE BEST MISTAKE MYSTERY by Sylvia McNicoll

THE BEST MISTAKE MYSTERY

From the "Great Mistake Mysteries" series, volume 1
Age Range: 9 - 12
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A bomb threat leads to early school dismissal and leaves Stephen entangled in intrigue.

Stephen likes to count his mistakes and has a tendency to read too much into things. These qualities don’t make him a favorite of his grade-seven classmates, but they do make him especially fit to solve a crime involving a rogue Volkswagen Beetle and a bomb threat. Additionally, Stephen has just been entrusted with his first dog-walking job. The boisterous dogs, Ping and Pong, are mismatched in size, hard to control, and irresistible. When Stephen is an unwitting witness to a serious incident, the dogs become a target of threats. Stephen begrudgingly allows his classmate Renée, the only other student as brainy and perhaps less popular than he, to assist him in figuring out the culprit and protecting the pups. Counting his mistakes throughout the day as a kind of deductive reasoning, Stephen gradually arrives at the culprit from among the likely suspects of the all-white cast of characters. Stephen is a slightly older Encyclopedia Brown plunked into a modern-day, unsavory scenario. The school violence is treated oddly lightly, so the balance of tone versus content is off-kilter. The descriptions of canine exuberance, however, are delightful and the best parts of this quick read and first in a promised mystery series.

Readers who can get past the tonal quibbles will appreciate seeing how this class geek discovers that some of his brainy quirks make him a fine budding sleuth. (Mystery. 9-12)

Pub Date: Jan. 31st, 2017
ISBN: 978-1-4597-3625-2
Page count: 160pp
Publisher: Dundurn
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 15th, 2016




MORE BY SYLVIA MCNICOLL

ChildrenTHE SNAKE MISTAKE MYSTERY by Sylvia McNicoll
by Sylvia McNicoll
ChildrenTHE ARTSY MISTAKE MYSTERY by Sylvia McNicoll
by Sylvia McNicoll
ChildrenREVENGE ON THE FLY by Sylvia McNicoll
by Sylvia McNicoll

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenEVIL SPY SCHOOL by Stuart Gibbs
by Stuart Gibbs
ChildrenTHE CASE OF THE ROCK ’N’ ROLL DOG by Martha Freeman
by Martha Freeman
ChildrenCHOMP by Carl Hiaasen
by Carl Hiaasen