TREE GIRL by T.A. Barron


Age Range: 8 - 11
Email this review


In this short fantasy novel, nine-year-old Rowanna, who lives in an isolated cottage with an old fisherman she calls Master, longs to learn more about her mother. Master has forbidden Rowanna to enter the woods near the cottage, which he claims are full of dangerous tree ghouls. But a playful young bear coaxes Rowanna into the woods and after they becomes friends, she spends her days there. On High Hallow Eve, the two friends take a day-long journey to find the tree where Master discovered Rowanna as a baby. A wild night ensues when the tree spirits emerge and dance with joy, and Rowanna learns the secret of her mother, who is a willow tree. The revelation, though, creates a major inconsistency in the fantasy, causing the reader to wonder why the mother’s tree spirit didn’t simply rescue Rowanna years earlier. Barron (The Wings of Merlin, 2000, etc.) writes lyrically about the forest and seasons, but he has unfortunately tried to give the language an old-fashioned sound by repeated use of words like “mayhaps” and “aye.” He also relies heavily on exclamation points and italics to add emotion. For example, when Rowanna sees a drawing in the sand, she realizes, “It was the face of the master himself! Aye, that it was!” The uncomplicated, slightly predictable story will appeal only to fantasy and fairy-tale lovers who can overlook the often stilted prose. Forsooth. (Fiction 8-11)

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2001
ISBN: 0-399-23457-8
Page count: 128pp
Publisher: Philomel
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2001


ChildrenATLANTIS LOST by T.A. Barron
by T.A. Barron
ChildrenATLANTIS IN PERIL by T.A. Barron
by T.A. Barron
ChildrenTHE WISDOM OF MERLIN by T.A. Barron
by T.A. Barron