BLACK EARTH by Timothy Snyder

BLACK EARTH

The Holocaust as History and Warning
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A prominent historian brings the Holocaust under new scrutiny and wonders if the right confluence of modern forces could bring genocide back.

Snyder (History/Yale Univ.) polarized academics and other experts on the Holocaust with his study Bloodlands: Europe Between Hitler and Stalin (2010), and he largely continues that line of thinking here as he attempts to contextualize the events that led up to the systematic extermination of 6 million Jews. The author argues that Hitler saw the world in terms of a twisted kind of ecology, one in which he saw Jews as a mistake to be removed. He also glances off the myth of Judeo-Bolshevism, the mistaken concept that Jews were behind the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia, but he admits that there's no excuse for claims of ignorance of these graphic events. “What happened in the second half of 1941 was an accelerating campaign of murder that took a million Jewish lives and apparently convinced the German leadership that all Jews under their control could be eliminated,” Snyder writes. “This calamity cannot be explained by stereotypes of passive or community Jews, of orderly or preprogrammed Germans, of beastly or antisemitic locals, or indeed by any other cliché, no matter how powerful at the time, or how convenient today. It would have been impossible without a special kind of politics.” In addition to probing the intellectual origins of the Final Solution, the author also offers thoughtful portrayals of Jews who survived execution and how institutions and states, as well as specific individuals, were crucial in these rescues. Snyder argues that the Holocaust should stand as a warning for our own future, but his conclusion is rather tepid in its analysis, with simplistic pronouncements that “our forgetfulness convinces us that we are different from Nazis by shrouding the ways that we are the same.”

A scholarly examination that poses important questions but ultimately offers less in the way of original reportage than Nikolaus Wachsmann’s KL (2015).

Pub Date: Sept. 8th, 2015
ISBN: 978-1-101-90345-2
Page count: 464pp
Publisher: Tim Duggan Books/Crown
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2015




OUR CRITICS' TAKES ON MORE BESTSELLERS

See full list >
Cover art for SCYTHE
VERDICT:
BUY IT
Cover art for SETTLE FOR MORE
VERDICT:
BORROW IT
Cover art for SCRAPPY LITTLE NOBODY
VERDICT:
BORROW IT
Cover art for THANK YOU FOR BEING LATE
VERDICT:
BUY IT

MORE BY TIMOTHY SNYDER

NonfictionTHINKING THE TWENTIETH CENTURY by Tony Judt
by Tony Judt
NonfictionBLOODLANDS by Timothy Snyder
by Timothy Snyder
NonfictionTHE RED PRINCE by Timothy Snyder
by Timothy Snyder

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionKL by Nikolaus Wachsmann
by Nicholas Wachsmann
NonfictionBLOODLANDS by Timothy Snyder
by Timothy Snyder
NonfictionTHE ORIGINS OF NAZI GENOCIDE by Henry Friedlander
by Henry Friedlander