THAT OLD BLACK MAGIC by Tom Clavin

THAT OLD BLACK MAGIC

Louis Prima, Keely Smith, and the Golden Age of Las Vegas

KIRKUS REVIEW

Lazy, hackneyed biography of the lounge act to end them all.

Former New York Times contributing reporter Clavin (Sir Walter: Walter Hagen and the Invention of Professional Golf, 2005, etc.) provides a gee-whiz look at singer-trumpeter Louis Prima’s Las Vegas heyday with spouse and musical partner Keely Smith. Enthralled by fellow New Orleans native Louis Armstrong, Italian-American Prima began his musical career in the 1920s and became a popular fixture at New York’s during the ’30s. Forced to break up his big band by changing tastes, Prima was down on his heels in 1954 when, out of desperation, he took a gig at the Sahara Hotel’s Casbar Lounge, doing five sets a night from midnight to 6 a.m. Rambunctious Prima, deadpan Smith and their high-voltage band quickly became the toast of Vegas, and they were recording stars pulling down a million-dollar salary by the time divorce broke up their act in 1961. Clavin appears utterly unqualified to parse Prima’s musical style, which combined the sound of the small black R&B combos, who rose during the ’40s as the big-band era waned, with his own Italianate repertoire and extroverted showmanship. The author also provides very few primary sources and offers no explanation of why Smith failed to sit down for an interview. Most of the material is dredged up from past tomes about Vegas’ showbiz and mob history, yellowing press clippings and previous film biographies of Prima. Extreme padding is evident in passages that catalog contemporaneous movie-house attractions and TV broadcasts for no apparent reason. The main narrative is larded further with threadbare recaps of Vegas’ history as a playground for Frank Sinatra’s Rat Pack and gangsters like Sam Giancana. Clavin’s fondness for cliché, idolatrous tone and unwillingness to supply even a glimmering of intelligent analysis make for torturous reading.

There’s no magic, black or otherwise, in this cut-and-paste bio.

Pub Date: Nov. 1st, 2010
ISBN: 978-1-55652-821-7
Page count: 240pp
Publisher: Chicago Review
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 15th, 2010




THE MOST DISAPPOINTING NONFICTION OF 2010:

Nonfiction LONG WAY HOME by Bill Barich
by Bill Barich
Nonfiction SLEEPWALK WITH ME by Mike Birbiglia
by Mike Birbiglia
Nonfiction EXTRA LIVES by Tom Bissell
by Tom Bissell
Nonfiction SPENT by Avis Cardella
by Avis Cardella

MORE BY TOM CLAVIN

NonfictionTHE HEART OF EVERYTHING THAT IS by Bob Drury
by Bob Drury
NonfictionTHE DIMAGGIOS by Tom Clavin
by Tom Clavin
NonfictionGIL HODGES by Tom Clavin
by Tom Clavin

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionAMORE by Mark Rotella
by Mark Rotella
NonfictionMAKING RECORDS by Phil Ramone
by Phil Ramone
NonfictionSINGING WAS THE EASY PART by Vic Damone
by Vic Damone