GOOD PROSE by Tracy Kidder
Kirkus Star


The Art of Nonfiction
Email this review


Legendary literary journalist Kidder (Strength in What Remains, 2009, etc.) and his longtime editor trade war stories and advice for the ambitious nonfiction writer.

“Let’s face it, this fellow can’t write,” an Atlantic editor told Todd about Kidder, who had been constantly revising his first feature in 1973. The authors tell this story upfront as an inspirational anecdote for young writers: Great writing is less often the product of flashes of genius than it is dogged persistence as a researcher and rewriter. The book is largely an entertaining handbook on matters of reporting (do lots of it, much more than you think you need) and style (simpler is better), but Kidder and Todd are not prescriptive the way Strunk & White and its inheritors are, and they allow greater leeway for writers. Throughout, they implore writers to shrug off the shackles of “journalese” and blog-y posturing and strive for creative, essayistic approaches. They’re also forgiving, to a degree, of the imperfect memories that propel many memoirs. Outright fabrications (see James Frey) are out of line for them, but they appreciate that no memoirs “that strive to dramatize moments in the past can be wholly faithful to knowable fact.” After the practical matters are settled, the two indulge in “Being Edited and Editor,” a lengthy chapter in which they recall their contentious relationship tussling over paragraphs. Even here, though, the memories are studded with practical tips and memorable aphorisms—“Something is always wrong with a draft,” in particular, should hang over every writer’s desk. The authors also offer fine recommendations for further reading, from Frank Conroy’s Stop-Time (1967) to Katherine Boo’s Behind the Beautiful Forevers (2012).

Other writing guides have more nuts-and-bolts advice, but few combine the verve and plainspokenness of this book, which exemplifies its title.

Pub Date: Jan. 8th, 2013
ISBN: 978-1-4000-6975-0
Page count: 224pp
Publisher: Random House
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Oct. 15th, 2012


NonfictionGOOD PROSE by Tracy Kidder
by Tracy Kidder
NonfictionP.G. WODEHOUSE by P.G. Wodehouse
by P.G. Wodehouse
NonfictionTHE UNIVERSE WITHIN by Neil Shubin
by Neil Shubin
NonfictionFAREWELL, FRED VOODOO by Amy Wilentz
by Amy Wilentz
NonfictionTHE DISASTER DIARIES by Sam Sheridan
by Sam Sheridan


NonfictionA TRUCK FULL OF MONEY by Tracy Kidder
by Tracy Kidder
NonfictionSTRENGTH IN WHAT REMAINS by Tracy Kidder
by Tracy Kidder
NonfictionMY DETACHMENT by Tracy Kidder
by Tracy Kidder


NonfictionTHE TRUE SECRET OF WRITING by Natalie Goldberg
by Natalie Goldberg
NonfictionON WRITING by Stephen King
by Stephen King
NonfictionBIRD BY BIRD by Anne Lamott
by Anne Lamott