NW by Zadie Smith


Email this review


A wildly ambitious jigsaw puzzle of a novel, one that shuffles pieces of chronology, identity, ethnicity and tone, undermining cohesion and narrative momentum as it attempts to encompass a London neighborhood that is both fixed and fluid.

Many of Smith’s strengths as a writer are journalistic—a keen eye for significant detail, ear for speech inflections, appreciation for cultural signifiers and distinctions—as she demonstrated in her previous collection (Changing My Mind: Occasional Essays, 2009). Yet, she first earned renown as a novelist with her breakthrough debut (White Teeth, 2000), and her fourth novel (first in six years) finds her challenging herself and the reader like never before. The title refers to “North West London, a dinky part of it you’ve never heard of called Willesden, and...you’d be wrong to dismiss it actually because actually it’s very interesting, very ‘diverse.’ Lord, what a word.” What initially seems to be a comedy of manners, involving two women who have been lifelong friends but now feel a distance in the disparity of their social standing (the one raised poorer by a Caribbean mother has done far better than the middle-class Caucasian), ultimately turns darker with abortion, murder, drug addiction and the possibility of a suicide. Much of the drama pivots on chance encounters (or fate?), making the plot difficult to summarize and even a protagonist hard to pinpoint. Each of the book’s parts also has a very different structure, ranging from very short chapters to an extended narrative interlude to numbered sections that might be as short as a paragraph or a page. The pivotal figure in the novel goes by two different names and has no fixed identity (other than her professional achievement as a barrister), and she doesn’t begin to tell the back story that dominates the novel’s second half until the first half concludes (it highlights different characters). “At some point we became aware of being ‘modern,’ of changing fast,” interjects the author, who has written a novel so modern that nothing flows or fits together in the conventional sense, but whose voice remains so engaging and insights so incisive that fans will persevere to make of it what they will.

Smith takes big risks here, but some might need to read this twice before all the pieces fit together, and more conventionally minded readers might abandon it in frustration.

Pub Date: Sept. 4th, 2012
ISBN: 978-1-594-20397-8
Page count: 400pp
Publisher: Penguin Press
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 15th, 2012


FictionSKAGBOYS by Irvine Welsh
by Irvine Welsh
FictionTHE MIDDLESTEINS by Jami Attenberg
by Jami Attenberg
FictionTELEGRAPH AVENUE by Michael Chabon
by Michael Chabon
FictionHOSTAGE by Elie Wiesel
by Elie Wiesel
MysteryA KILLING IN THE HILLS by Julia Keller
by Julia Keller


NonfictionFEEL FREE by Zadie Smith
by Zadie Smith
FictionSWING TIME by Zadie Smith
by Zadie Smith
NonfictionCHANGING MY MIND by Zadie Smith
by Zadie Smith
FictionON BEAUTY by Zadie Smith
by Zadie Smith


FictionTHE PRIVILEGES by Jonathan Dee
by Jonathan Dee
FictionTHE CASUAL VACANCY by J.K. Rowling
by J.K. Rowling
FictionCLAY by Melissa Harrison
by Melissa Harrison
FictionFREEDOM by Jonathan Franzen
by Jonathan Franzen