A Story of Choice
Email this review


The inspiring story of a peace advocate who was raised in the dogma of hate but chose a different path.

With the assistance of journalist Giles, Ebrahim conjures a child’s voice as he tells the story of his life thus far. The book opens with a shock: The author is 7 years old, living in New Jersey, and it’s the middle of the night. His mother is shaking him awake and telling him to pack his things; there’s been an accident, someone is hurt, and they must go to a hospital in Brooklyn. It turns out that his father, El-Sayyid Nosair, has assassinated Meir Kahane, leader of the Jewish Defense League, and is a protégé of Omar Abdel-Rahman, the fundamentalist “Blind Sheik.” Later, Ebrahim’s father was also convicted of helping plot the first World Trade Center bombing from prison. Throughout the book, the author is all youthful anxiety: confused, fearful, bullied, angry, self-loathing. Despite the clarity of the writing, these emotions are experienced through a glass darkly and are spooky to the point of chilling. Ebrahim explains how easy it is to implant bigotry in children: “Alexander Graham Bell invented the telephone. Pi equals 3.14. All Jews are evil, and homosexuality is an abomination. Paris is the capital of France.” They sound like facts; a child can’t tell the difference, and they fear the “other.” As the author notes, bigotry is “such a maddeningly perfect circle.” Ebrahim could easily have trod that path, but his mother was a counterforce, somehow teaching her son empathy, and she stunned him with six simple words: “I’m so sick of hating people.”

Ebrahim turns Auden’s cautionary words on evil upside down with this brief but moving “portrait of a young man who was raised in the fires of fanaticism and embraced nonviolence instead.”

Pub Date: Sept. 9th, 2014
ISBN: 978-1-4767-8480-9
Page count: 112pp
Publisher: TED/Simon & Schuster
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1st, 2014


NonfictionROOKIE COP by Richard Rosenthal
by Richard Rosenthal
NonfictionTHE LONGEST WAR by Peter L. Bergen
by Peter L. Bergen
NonfictionTHE WAY OF THE KNIFE by Mark Mazzetti
by Mark Mazzetti