THE LOST CHILD by Caryl Phillips
Kirkus Star


Email this review


Award-winning novelist, essayist and playwright Phillips (Color Me English, 2011, etc.) responds to Wuthering Heights.

A difficult daughter and an unhappy wife, Monica Johnson is contrary, self-destructive and—finally—mad. That Monica, in her broad outlines, resembles Cathy Earnshaw is no accident. Her story—as well as that of her husband and their sons—is interwoven with scenes inspired by Wuthering Heights and the life of its author. This is not to say that Monica is Cathy, transplanted from the moors to Oxford in the late 1950s. This is not a retelling. The interplay between this novel and Emily Brontë’s masterpiece is much more interesting than that. For example, Phillips imagines Heathcliff before Mr. Earnshaw takes him to the Heights. This boy is the son of a slave, a woman who worked a sugar plantation before being transported to England. Phillips isn’t the first to read Brontë’s “dark-skinned” antihero as black, but he also connects the boy to Monica’s husband, Julius—a man who gives up academic life in order to take up the cause of anti-colonialism in his West Indian home country—and to their neglected, dispossessed sons. The thematic links between the modern story and Wuthering Heights only become clear over time, and—even then—they’re too rich and subtle to work as simple allegory. Empire and race are among Phillips’ concerns, but he also offers heartbreaking depictions of alienation and the fragility of human relationships. While it would be easy to identify Heathcliff as the lost child of the title, it could also refer to Monica’s younger son—or her older boy. But Monica is lost, too. And then there’s Brontë, drifting further and further into her invented world as she dies. What Phillips seems to be saying, in the end, is that the lost child could be any of us—perhaps even that the lost child is all of us.

Gorgeously crafted and emotionally shattering.

Pub Date: March 10th, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-374-19137-5
Page count: 272pp
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 1st, 2015


FictionDAYS OF AWE by Lauren Fox
by Lauren Fox
ChildrenARCHIVIST WASP by Nicole Kornher-Stace
by Nicole Kornher-Stace
NonfictionFATHERLAND by Nina Bunjevac
by Nina Bunjevac
FictionDIETLAND by Sarai Walker
by Sarai Walker


NonfictionCOLOR ME ENGLISH by Caryl Phillips
by Caryl Phillips
FictionIN THE FALLING SNOW  by Caryl Phillips
by Caryl Phillips
FictionFOREIGNERS by Caryl Phillips
by Caryl Phillips


IndieMERCHANT OF DREAMS by Anita Briggs
by Anita Briggs
FictionBRICK LANE by Monica Ali
by Monica Ali