SAINT FRANCIS OF ASSISI by Géraldine Elschner

SAINT FRANCIS OF ASSISI

Who Spoke to the Animals
Age Range: 8 - 12
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

This life of the popular saint is illustrated with works of art and features quotes from Pope Francis.

It is difficult to pin down the audience for this biography. Kids will need understandings of brothers as monks (as opposed to relatives), lepers, and stigmata. The sometimes-difficult concepts and sophisticated artwork demand an older audience than the picture-book format it is likely to attract. Elschner writes (in an uncredited translation), “Francis sought poverty as his companion in life.” The text refers to Francis’ famous Canticle of the Sun, but it’s just that: a reference, not a description or the text of it. And Elschner describes a Christmas Eve service Francis held: “He sent an ox and a donkey to a cave. He filled the manger with fresh hay. There lay the child.” Wait. What child? The historical works of art that depict the life of Saint Francis, while beautiful, also may confuse young readers, as Francis’ appearance changes from page to page. In one instance, before the page that talks of his death, he appears in a cloud above a sick child, seemingly dead himself. In another, the chosen illustration depicts not the stigmata that the majority of the text talks about but Francis’ follower Sylvester’s expulsion of evil spirits from a town. Pope Francis’ quotes are mostly relevant to the content on the page and include date and event references.

This fails to capture the joy of the saint so often associated with a love of nature. (Picture book/biography. 8-12)

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2017
ISBN: 978-988-8341-44-3
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Minedition
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1st, 2017




MORE BY GÉRALDINE ELSCHNER

ChildrenMY LITTLE CHICK by Géraldine Elschner
by Géraldine Elschner
ChildrenPOMPON by Géraldine Elschner
by Géraldine Elschner
ChildrenTHE THREE KINGS by Géraldine Elschner
by Géraldine Elschner

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenSAINT FRANCIS AND THE WOLF by Richard Egielski
by Richard Egielski
ChildrenTHE SONG OF FRANCIS by Tomie dePaola
by Tomie dePaola
ChildrenTHE DAY THE ANIMALS CAME by Frances Ward Weller
by Frances Ward Weller