Alert readers expect a certain amount of bombast from editors of "best of" anthologies; but, as Asimov remarks in his introduction (his emphasis): "I don't know any great scientists who are great science fiction writers." The by-line is similarly elastic, including "scientists" "who obtained the education to become such, but drifted away." It's not even an original idea for an anthology. And so to the contents: 21 stories, 1954-85, except for one turn-of-the-century antique, a sort of talky prototype of Borges' "The Library of Babel," from Kurd Lasswitz. The better, well-known entries include: Arthur C. Clarke's space race in ships propelled by solar sails, "The Wind from the Sun"; J.F. Bone's masterful tale of amoeba-like aliens (Martians?) encountering an enigmatic (NASA?) space probe; James V. McConnell's thin but original look at experimental psychology from the rat's viewpoint; "Love is the Plan the Plan is Death," James Tiptree Jr.'s powerful tale of loving, cannibalistic aliens struggling to cope with a deteriorating climate; and from Chad Oliver, a strong humans-really-come-from-outer-space yarn, "Transfusion." The remaining tales feature some fair ideas in often lifeless treatments: tiny, super-dense aliens; a space elevator; a cyborg spaceship; linguistic problems; involuntary population control; historical fantasies; witches; and hyperspace. A few goodies, then, but generally mediocre and disappointing.
Thank you! You’ll get the first email of recommendations from our critics within a week!
Bummer. There was a problem adding your email address. Please try again.
Subscribe to Pro Connect
Be the first to discover new talent!
Each week, our editors select the one author and one book they believe to be most worthy of your attention and highlight them in our Pro Connect email alert.
Sign up here to receive your FREE alerts.