GEORGE WASHINGTON by James MacGregor Burns

GEORGE WASHINGTON

KIRKUS REVIEW

George Washington: a so-so general, at least at the start; a capable politician, even if he didn’t particularly enjoy pressing the flesh.

But a great president? This slender volume in Arthur Schlesinger’s American Presidents series, by political historian Burns (Dead Center, 1999, etc.) and revolutionary-era historian Dunn (Sister Revolutions, 1999), hints that some of Washington’s renown in that department has to do only with his being the first in the job. Yet, they add, Washington did much in office to recast the role of the chief executive as the energetic center of government, to the discomfort of contemporaries who believed that therein lay the road to kingship; his model posited “vigorous executive leadership, a flexible and resourceful administration, presidential rather than party leadership—a model that overrode the checks and balances without blatantly violating the spirit of the Constitution but that threatened to pulverize the opposition.” Other presidents have followed Washington’s lead to a fault, raising “formidable threats of excessive presidential power, as in the cases of a Lyndon B. Johnson and a George W. Bush,” but his legacy has largely been modified by the evolution of a two-party system that requires a little more teamwork on the president’s part. Burns and Dunn capably chart the course of Washington’s presidency, examining what they consider to be his successes (including the reshaping of the constitutional balance of powers) and failures (among them the polarization wrought by the Jay Treaty, which “left much that was precious to Washington—national unity, the common good, his own reputation—in tatters”). In the end, they fault him only gently for occasional missteps in office, notably his failure to act to hasten the end of slavery.

A great president, then, if with a few blemishes. Good reading for students of the office and the time.

Pub Date: Jan. 7th, 2004
ISBN: 0-8050-6936-4
Page count: 224pp
Publisher: Henry Holt
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 15th, 2003




MORE BY JAMES MACGREGOR BURNS

NonfictionFIRE AND LIGHT by James MacGregor Burns
by James MacGregor Burns
NonfictionPACKING THE COURT by James MacGregor Burns
by James MacGregor Burns
NonfictionDEAD CENTER by James MacGregor Burns
by James MacGregor Burns

MORE BY SUSAN DUNN

Nonfiction1940 by Susan Dunn
by Susan Dunn
NonfictionDOMINION OF MEMORIES by Susan Dunn
by Susan Dunn
NonfictionJEFFERSON’S SECOND REVOLUTION by Susan Dunn
by Susan Dunn

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionGEORGE WASHINGTON by Stephen Brumwell
by Stephen Brumwell
NonfictionWHERE THE CHERRY TREE GREW by Philip Levy
by Philip Levy