THE MORNING THEY CAME FOR US by Janine di Giovanni
Kirkus Star


Dispatches from Syria
Email this review


Newsweek Middle East editor di Giovanni (Ghosts by Daylight: A Modern-Day War Correspondent's Memoir of Love, Loss, and Redemption, 2013) dives headfirst into the nightmarish shadow world of modern Syria.

At the beginning, the author relates how a diplomat friend told her “not to start working in Syria. He said it would engulf me as Bosnia had done, and he suggested gently that this was probably not a good thing emotionally. Even so, I went.” Throughout the story, di Giovanni’s quest seems almost suicidal, but the fruits of her labor are astonishing. She profiles ordinary Syrians struggling to survive while also chronicling her own death-defying journey. Locals guided her through ruined churches, bomb-addled tenements, and dubious border crossings. Even as Western readers have gradually begun to understand the complexities of the Syrian conflict, di Giovanni brings daily life into focus. “What does war sound like?” she asks. “The whistling sound of the bombs falling can only be heard seconds before impact—enough time to know that you are about to die, but not enough time to flee. What does the war in Aleppo smell of? It smells of carbine, of wood smoke, of unwashed bodies, or rubbish rotting, of the heady smell of fear.” In her gutsy and sensitive narrative, the author offers the surreal imagery of a place without reason. During her first drive to Damascus, she stopped at a roadside Dunkin’ Donuts serving only cheese sandwiches. Later, a physician took a break from his dying patients to play a lonely game of foosball on the hospital roof. Di Giovanni interweaves biblical references and anecdotes about her own motherhood into the story, which may strike some readers as forced or even melodramatic. But the author is a master of war reporting, especially its civilian side. Thanks to her bitter sacrifice, Western readers may begin to appreciate the chaos that Syrian refugees continue to flee.

This brilliant, necessary book will hopefully do for Syria what Herr’s Dispatches (1977) did for Vietnam.

Pub Date: May 3rd, 2016
ISBN: 978-0-87140-713-9
Page count: 320pp
Publisher: Liveright/Norton
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1st, 2016


NonfictionGHOSTS BY DAYLIGHT by Janine di Giovanni
by Janine di Giovanni
NonfictionMADNESS VISIBLE by Janine di Giovanni
by Janine di Giovanni


NonfictionSYRIA by John McHugo
by John McHugo
NonfictionSYRIA SPEAKS by Malu Halasa
by Malu Halasa
NonfictionSTRINGER by Anjan Sundaram
by Anjan Sundaram
NonfictionTHE DOGS ARE EATING THEM NOW by Graeme Smith
by Graeme Smith