MAKE ME A CITY by Jonathan Carr


Age Range: 1800 - 1900
Email this review


The rise of Chicago in the 19th century provides the frame for a trove of colorful stories and characters in this entertaining debut novel.

The first chapter begins with a wink, a label describing it as an “Extract from Chicago: An Alternative History 1800-1900." That conceit also prepares for the book’s variety of textual “sources,” including a journal, letters, a chapbook, newspaper clips, an interview, and, in a meta wink, a book review of the alternative history. They give a period feel, add colorful voices via dialect and accents, and allow Carr some narrative maneuvers. The story traces the building of the city from muddy streets to bubble-frame houses, sewage systems, and skyscrapers while following several characters across generations. One is the city’s first settler, whose father was a white Frenchman and mother, "a free-born slave"; his great-granddaughter will become a journalist and take on powerful politicians, putting her life at risk in a chilling scene. Another is a dreamer and booster of Chicago who begins with land speculation, goes bankrupt twice, and plays a crucial role in making the city a railroad hub. He is also foiled in a romance that will echo across years. Elsewhere a teen nearly killed while trying to break up a logjam delaying timber shipments to the growing city will become a building inspector and target of the same corrupt politicians the journalist pursues. A few historical figures have cameos, although Ellis Chesbrough, the engineer who designed Chicago's sewer system, gets a sizable role linked to the fictional players. Melodrama mars a few scenes, and the frequent shifts in voice and style may test some readers’ patience. For the most part, Carr has a sure touch, and in many extended anecdotes, his narrative skills show exceptional detail, pacing, and tension.

A solid storyteller enlivens a rich patch of American history.

Pub Date: March 19th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-250-29401-2
Page count: 448pp
Publisher: Henry Holt
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Dec. 15th, 2018


NonfictionTHE WAGNER CLAN by Jonathan Carr
by Jonathan Carr
NonfictionMAHLER by Jonathan Carr
by Jonathan Carr


FictionTHE LAKE ON FIRE by Rosellen Brown
by Rosellen Brown
FictionGOLDEN HILL by Francis Spufford
by Francis Spufford
FictionTHE JUDGE HUNTER by Christopher Buckley
by Christopher Buckley