MYSTERY IN MAYAN MEXICO by Marcia Wells

MYSTERY IN MAYAN MEXICO

From the "Eddie Red Undercover" series, volume 2
by , illustrated by
Age Range: 9 - 11
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A free trip to the Yucatán pitches Edmund, a young artist/sleuth with a photographic memory, and his OCD pal Jonah into a new investigation involving an unsolved old crime and disappearing gold.

Edmund opens his account sitting in a jail cell, clad in a wet Darth Vader costume, covered in scratches, blood and barf (“I smell awesome”), his wrist in a cast—and really not looking forward to calling his parents. Following this magnificent lead-in, though, the tale goes downhill rapidly, from the disappearance of an ancient gold mask to the climactic struggle with a knife-wielding thief atop a rain-swept Mayan ruin. In between, Wells concocts a nonsensically contrived caper involving Hebrew orthography, poorly integrated “evidence” from false fingerprints to glimpses of the bad guy dressed as a museum guard, and an obvious, no-brainer clue to where the gold is hidden that has somehow gone misunderstood for decades. Moreover, even less-reflective readers will wonder how Edmund and Jonah can break into an apartment and bend various other laws in the course of their investigation without suffering any legal consequences. Along the way, Jonah’s practice of smearing a gift-store Mayan effigy with peanut-butter and blood “sacrifices” comes off more like cultural mockery than harmless fooling. Calo’s accomplished drawings bring characters and details to life but are both rare and, sometimes, too finished to believably represent Edmund’s quick sketches.

Comical and clever in spots but overall, a sad follow-up to Mystery on Museum Mile (2014). (appendix of Mayan gods) (Mystery. 9-11)

Pub Date: April 7th, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-544-30206-8
Page count: 224pp
Publisher: HMH Books
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 1st, 2015




MORE BY MARCIA WELLS

ChildrenDOOM AT GRANT'S TOMB by Marcia Wells
by Marcia Wells
ChildrenMYSTERY ON MUSEUM MILE by Marcia Wells
by Marcia Wells

MORE BY MARCOS CALO

ChildrenDOOM AT GRANT'S TOMB by Marcia Wells
by Marcia Wells
ChildrenMYSTERY ON MUSEUM MILE by Marcia Wells
by Marcia Wells
ChildrenTHE MYSTERY OF THE GOLD COIN by Harper Paris
by Harper Paris

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenHOW TO BE A DETECTIVE by Dan Waddell
by Dan Waddell
ChildrenHOCUS POCUS HOTEL by Lisa K. Weber
by Michael Dahl
ChildrenTHE OSTRICH CONSPIRACY by Jarrett J. Krosoczka
by Jarrett J. Krosoczka