ROSE by Martin Cruz Smith


Email this review


 Smith (Red Square, 1992, etc.) not only sets his exuberant, sly new novel in Victorian England but goes Victorian novelists one better, conjuring up a plot device at the heart of this mystery that Dickens would envy. Set in the town of Wigan, in Lancashire, this latest from Smith doesn't simply evoke the past, it plunges us into the gritty reality of a mid-19th-century community dominated by its vast coal mines. We learn an extraordinary amount about the brutal world of mining, but more importantly we come to feel a part of Wigan, so actual do its streets and inhabitants seem. It's this dense world that lingers: The plot is, with its one exception, a rather unsurprising mystery. Jonathan Blair, a mining engineer and explorer who has returned from Africa under a cloud (there are rumors of fraud), is summoned by his erstwhile employer, Bishop Hannay (who owns much of Wigan, including its largest coal mine), and set on the trail of the fianceÇ of Hannay's daughter Charlotte. John Maypole, a fervent young minister, had disappeared on the same day that an explosion in Hannay's mine killed 75 men. Charlotte, bright, acerbic, radical, takes an immediate dislike to the laconic Blair. He, in turn, is fascinated by Rose Molyneux, a remarkably independent ``pit girl'' (women employed by the mines, pit girls are notorious in England for their clothes--they wear trousers under vestigial dresses--and the supposed easiness of their morals). Blair is menaced by two miners, blithe sadists determined to stop his inquiry. A dogged, shrewd investigator, he takes a huge amount of punishment before uncovering Maypole's sad fate. And, in the midst of a dangerous affair with Rose, he discovers the remarkable scheme linking her and Charlotte Hannay. It's a dazzling moment. Blair, Rose, and Smith's other characters are wonderful creations, robust and distinctive. The crimes here are unremarkable, but the world evoked is memorable, glowing with life. (Author tour)

Pub Date: May 1st, 1996
ISBN: 0-679-42661-2
Page count: 368pp
Publisher: Random House
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 1996


FictionTHE GIRL FROM VENICE by Martin Cruz Smith
by Martin Cruz Smith
FictionTATIANA by Martin Cruz Smith
by Martin Cruz Smith
FictionSTALIN’S GHOST by Martin Cruz Smith
by Martin Cruz Smith


MysteryA DEATH IN THE SMALL HOURS by Charles Finch
by Charles Finch
MysteryTHE FEMALE DETECTIVE by Andrew Forrester
by Andrew Forrester
MysteryA BURIAL AT SEA by Charles Finch
by Charles Finch