THE STORY OF BEAUTIFUL GIRL by Rachel Simon

THE STORY OF BEAUTIFUL GIRL

KIRKUS REVIEW

Outrage against a mental-health system no longer in service is the guiding force in this pointedly uplifting love story from novelist and memoirist Simon (Riding the Bus with My Sister, 2002, which became a Hallmark Hall of Fame movie) about a deaf African-American man and a mentally disabled woman who meet in a Dickensian mental institution in the 1960s and overcome all obstacles through force of will and spiritual goodness. 

In 1968, childless retired schoolteacher Martha briefly gives shelter to Lynnie and Homan, runaways from the residential facility in northern Pennsylvania, until the corrupt head doctor and his henchmen track them down. Homan gets away. Lynnie is taken back in a straightjacket, but the authorities don’t know about her newborn baby, delivered by Homan but the product of a rape. Keeping her promise to Lynnie, Martha hides infant Julia with the help of various former students and eventually raises her as her own granddaughter. Over the next four decades, Homan never ceases to long for Lynnie and the baby. Deaf since a childhood fever, he uses his street smarts, spiritual wisdom and mechanical skills to survive a picaresque series of adventures until he lands in California, where he more than prospers. Meanwhile, Lynnie remains in what she calls “the bad place,” where she was placed as a child by a middle-class parent embarrassed at her lack of cognitive skills. Fortunately, saintly staff member Alice helps Lynnie develop her artistic talent and keeps track of Julia through one of Martha’s students. The publication of an exposé on “the bad place” changes conditions in the late '70s. Gradually Lynnie learns to talk. She reunites with her beloved older sister Hannah, who sells Lynnie’s art in the gallery she runs. Now living independently, Lynnie still longs for Homan and Julia. The question is not if but how they will unite (and why resourceful Homan takes so long).

Despite engaging moments, Simon’s didactic tone strains readers’ patience.

Pub Date: May 4th, 2011
ISBN: 978-0-446-57446-4
Page count: 352pp
Publisher: Grand Central Publishing
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15th, 2011




MORE BY RACHEL SIMON

NonfictionBUILDING A HOME WITH MY HUSBAND by Rachel Simon
by Rachel Simon
NonfictionRIDING THE BUS WITH MY SISTER by Rachel Simon
by Rachel Simon
FictionTHE MAGIC TOUCH by Rachel Simon
by Rachel Simon

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

FictionNECESSARY LIES by Diane Chamberlain
by Diane Chamberlain
FictionTHE HELP by Kathryn  Stockett
by Kathryn Stockett
NonfictionTWIN by Allen Shawn
by Allen Shawn