MacMurray (1921–1997) was supposedly a great Dickinson fan, but with fans like her, who needs hostile, revisionist critics?


The Emily of the title, last name Dickinson, is an annoying, unpleasant genius, and even her genius is questionable in this literary fiction about a young Amherst woman befriended by the poet.

Mistakenly assumed to have inherited her mother’s tuberculosis, Arethusa Chase spends a lonely childhood in her family’s Boston mansion, her only joy the private tutoring she receives. After her neglectful mother’s death, Arethusa’s father takes her on a recuperative visit to Barbados, where she changes her name to Miranda after acting in The Tempest. The Chases move to Amherst, where Mr. Chase is a professor. After her pert resistance to a local minister’s attempt to have her “profess,” Miranda receives an invitation to visit Emily, already a recluse in her father’s house. Soon, Miranda is expected every Monday. At first, Miranda is bewitched by Emily’s unusual wit, but as time passes, she recognizes Emily’s tendency to be needy, selfish, even spiteful. The snatches of letters and poems included do little to improve Miranda’s, or the reader’s, opinion of the shrewish poet. No matter, Emily’s importance fades as Miranda’s loves and career ambitions take center stage. When her fiancé, Davy, dies in the Civil War, he bequeaths to Miranda a foundation to carry out her progressive ideas on early-childhood education. She begins a school with her former tutor. Meanwhile, her cousin Kate dies and Miranda semi-adopts Kate’s young daughter. Miranda’s independence threatens Emily, who is by turns jealous and distant during Miranda’s now less frequent visits. When Miranda falls in love with the executor of Davy’s estate (his wife, shades of Jane Eyre, alive but incapacitated by brain sickness), Emily manipulates Miranda into confiding the graphic details and then writes an anonymous letter to the board of Miranda’s school attempting to expose the affair. Discovering Emily’s betrayal, Miranda ends the friendship.

MacMurray (1921–1997) was supposedly a great Dickinson fan, but with fans like her, who needs hostile, revisionist critics?

Pub Date: April 24, 2007

ISBN: 0-316-01760-4

Page Count: 448

Publisher: Little, Brown

Review Posted Online: May 19, 2010

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15, 2007

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet



A flabby, fervid melodrama of a high-strung Southern family from Conroy (The Great Santini, The Lords of Discipline), whose penchant for overwriting once again obscures a genuine talent. Tom Wingo is an unemployed South Carolinian football coach whose internist wife is having an affair with a pompous cardiac man. When he hears that his fierce, beautiful twin sister Savannah, a well-known New York poet, has once again attempted suicide, he escapes his present emasculation by flying north to meet Savannah's comely psychiatrist, Susan Lowenstein. Savannah, it turns out, is catatonic, and before the suicide attempt had completely assumed the identity of a dead friend—the implication being that she couldn't stand being a Wingo anymore. Susan (a shrink with a lot of time on her hands) says to Tom, "Will you stay in New York and tell me all you know?" and he does, for nearly 600 mostly-bloated pages of flashbacks depicting The Family Wingo of swampy Colleton County: a beautiful mother, a brutal shrimper father (the Great Santini alive and kicking), and Tom and Savannah's much-admired older brother, Luke. There are enough traumas here to fall an average-sized mental ward, but the biggie centers around Luke, who uses the skills learned as a Navy SEAL in Vietnam to fight a guerrilla war against the installation of a nuclear power plant in Colleton and is killed by the authorities. It's his death that precipitates the nervous breakdown that costs Tom his job, and Savannah, almost, her life. There may be a barely-glimpsed smaller novel buried in all this succotash (Tom's marriage and life as a football coach), but it's sadly overwhelmed by the book's clumsy central narrative device (flashback ad infinitum) and Conroy's pretentious prose style: ""There are no verdicts to childhood, only consequences, and the bright freight of memory. I speak now of the sun-struck, deeply lived-in days of my past.

Pub Date: Oct. 21, 1986

ISBN: 0553381547

Page Count: 686

Publisher: Houghton Mifflin

Review Posted Online: Oct. 30, 2013

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 15, 1986

Did you like this book?

The story's very ambiguity steadily feeds its mysteriousness and power, and Danielewski's mastery of postmodernist and...


An amazingly intricate and ambitious first novel - ten years in the making - that puts an engrossing new spin on the traditional haunted-house tale.

Texts within texts, preceded by intriguing introductory material and followed by 150 pages of appendices and related "documents" and photographs, tell the story of a mysterious old house in a Virginia suburb inhabited by esteemed photographer-filmmaker Will Navidson, his companion Karen Green (an ex-fashion model), and their young children Daisy and Chad.  The record of their experiences therein is preserved in Will's film The Davidson Record - which is the subject of an unpublished manuscript left behind by a (possibly insane) old man, Frank Zampano - which falls into the possession of Johnny Truant, a drifter who has survived an abusive childhood and the perverse possessiveness of his mad mother (who is institutionalized).  As Johnny reads Zampano's manuscript, he adds his own (autobiographical) annotations to the scholarly ones that already adorn and clutter the text (a trick perhaps influenced by David Foster Wallace's Infinite Jest) - and begins experiencing panic attacks and episodes of disorientation that echo with ominous precision the content of Davidson's film (their house's interior proves, "impossibly," to be larger than its exterior; previously unnoticed doors and corridors extend inward inexplicably, and swallow up or traumatize all who dare to "explore" their recesses).  Danielewski skillfully manipulates the reader's expectations and fears, employing ingeniously skewed typography, and throwing out hints that the house's apparent malevolence may be related to the history of the Jamestown colony, or to Davidson's Pulitzer Prize-winning photograph of a dying Vietnamese child stalked by a waiting vulture.  Or, as "some critics [have suggested,] the house's mutations reflect the psychology of anyone who enters it."

The story's very ambiguity steadily feeds its mysteriousness and power, and Danielewski's mastery of postmodernist and cinema-derived rhetoric up the ante continuously, and stunningly.  One of the most impressive excursions into the supernatural in many a year.

Pub Date: March 6, 2000

ISBN: 0-375-70376-4

Page Count: 704

Publisher: Pantheon

Review Posted Online: May 19, 2010

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 1, 2000

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet