VOICES OF THE WESTERN FRONTIER by Sherry Garland

VOICES OF THE WESTERN FRONTIER

Age Range: 6 - 8
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A wide-angled overview of the settling of the American West in first-person, free-verse poems.

As the title implies, the era is regarded, even by the few non-Anglo witnesses, from a decidedly Eurocentric point of view. Garland opens with statements from Sacagawea (the only Native American), trapper Jedediah Smith, and George Catlin, but all of her other “voices” are anonymous ones ("I am a girl walking along the Oregon Trail") until Annie Oakley steps in toward the end. The observations are largely likewise generic—“Since the Louisiana Purchase twenty-two years ago, / trappers have been depleting the beaver everywhere,” complains Smith. They are occasionally cringe-inducing: the Chinese railroad worker is proud to have earned “respect from our bosses for a job well-done,” and the “Buffalo Soldier” identifies himself as “a former slave / who joined this all-Negro regiment in 1866.” A long historical note displays similar lack of sensitivity, capped by a claim that the Indian Wars were started by “renegades” out for payback for the slaughter of the buffalo. Depicted in period dress and settings, most of the improbably clean, largely light-skinned figures in Buckner’s painted portraits look directly at readers. The chronologically arranged entries end with a modern child at a rodeo, observing that “today the Indians wear boots and hats and jeans. / But for a little while, in front of cheering crowds, / the old Wild West lives once again.”

Painfully parochial. (glossary, map, bibliographies) (Informational picture book/poetry. 6-8)

Pub Date: Feb. 1st, 2016
ISBN: 978-1-4556-1961-0
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Pelican
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Dec. 15th, 2015




MORE BY SHERRY GARLAND

ChildrenTHE BUFFALO SOLDIER by Sherry Garland
by Sherry Garland
ChildrenCHILDREN OF THE DRAGON by Sherry Garland
by Sherry Garland
ChildrenMY FATHER'S BOAT by Sherry Garland
by Sherry Garland

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenCOWBOYS by Martin Sandler
by Martin Sandler
ChildrenA KID’S GUIDE TO NATIVE AMERICAN HISTORY by Yvonne Wakim Dennis
by Yvonne Wakim Dennis
ChildrenSACAGAWEA by Lise Erdrich
by Lise Erdrich