BETWEEN THE WATER AND THE WOODS by Simone Snaith

BETWEEN THE WATER AND THE WOODS

by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 11 - 14
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Village girl encounters magic, heads to the big city, and meets a handsome knight and steam-carriages.

Sixteen-year-old Emeline lives in a village so small and remote that they don’t even use money, but when she and her brother spot an Ithin, a legendary Dark Creature, they, along with their widowed father, a neighbor, and a stowaway, head to the capital: The law requires they report the sighting to the king in person. Along the way they meet a Lash Knight and become embroiled in the philosophical and political feud between Sapients and Theurgists. Lovely illustrations from Kipin (The Language of Thorns, 2017) elevate this debut but don’t make up for the nonexistent plot (mostly conversation and sightseeing) or the haphazard worldbuilding. Technology ranges from nonexistent to programmable automata; silver is used for bullets and any number of other uses for which it’s likely too soft; magic runs in the Keldare people, but at the same time anyone can join the Keldare. Imagination is on full display, but multiple threads compete to be the central seam, to the detriment of narrative flow. Note that the art depicts Emeline as darker-skinned and love interest Reese lighter; the text focuses mostly on fashion and finance, not skin tone, although some variation is implied.

Original but too sloppily executed for success. (Fantasy. 11-14)

Pub Date: March 19th, 2019
ISBN: 978-0-8234-4020-7
Page count: 320pp
Publisher: Holiday House
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 15th, 2019




SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenPLAIN KATE by Erin Bow
by Erin Bow
ChildrenTHE GIRL WHO DRANK THE MOON by Kelly  Barnhill
by Kelly Barnhill
ChildrenLEVIATHAN  by Scott Westerfeld
by Scott Westerfeld