THE MAGICAL WISHING FISH by The Brothers Grimm

THE MAGICAL WISHING FISH

by ; illustrated by ; translated by
Age Range: 4 - 7
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Bigger houses, more important titles: sounds like the wishes of many of today’s professionals and entrepreneurs.

But wait! This is an old tale of envy. This version of “The Fisherman and His Wife” hews closely to the original, although some significant (and unattributed) changes have been made. Here Isabel, the wife, asks to be a queen (not a king), and her wish to be pope (perhaps to smooth out the original’s overtly Christian content) is elided, the text jumping straight to her even more outrageous desire to be God. When the couple is reduced to living under an “old broken pot” once again (like a chamber pot, taken from the German “pissputt”), Isabel realizes that luxury and palaces never made her content, again deviating from the original. She moralizes: “God on Earth lived a simple life full of love and kindness, and I’m happy to live like that too.” The story is smoothly told, with fisherman Thomas’ dialogue to the fish introduced in rhyming verse. The sea roils in a wilder and wilder manner as the fish grows angrier and angrier with Isabel’s demands. The delicate paintings often have an ethereal, abstract quality, as in the picture of Isabel on an emperor’s golden throne, with a long flight of steps leading up to an indistinct, richly dressed seated figure. Poor Thomas sits at the bottom, turned away from her, holding his head, sad and scared, when she makes her last imperious request. Thomas and Isabel both present white.

Although an additional purchase for most purposes, this might have a place in a religious school or for a family of faith. (Picture book/fairy tale. 4-7)

Pub Date: Sept. 4th, 2018
ISBN: 978-1-78250-524-2
Page count: 24pp
Publisher: Floris
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1st, 2018




MORE BY THE BROTHERS GRIMM

ChildrenIN FAIRYLAND by The Brothers Grimm
by The Brothers Grimm
ChildrenTHE FROG PRINCE by The Brothers Grimm
by The Brothers Grimm
ChildrenFAIRY TALES FROM THE BROTHERS GRIMM by The Brothers Grimm
by The Brothers Grimm

MORE BY LOEK KOOPMANS

ChildrenTHE OX AND THE DONKEY by Günter Spang
by Günter Spang
ChildrenTHE CHRISTMAS VISITOR by Anneliese Lussert
by Anneliese Lussert

MORE BY POLLY LAWSON

ChildrenTHE HOUSE OF LOST AND FOUND by Martin Widmark
by Martin Widmark
ChildrenGOODNIGHT SANDMAN by Daniela Drescher
by Daniela Drescher
ChildrenSANTA CLAUS AND THE CHRISTMAS SURPRISE by Dorothea Lachner
by Dorothea Lachner

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenPLEASE, MR MAGIC FISH by Jessica Souhami
by Jessica Souhami
ChildrenTHE FISHERMAN AND HIS WIFE by Rachel Isadora
by Rachel Isadora
ChildrenTHE FISHERMAN AND HIS WIFE by Rosemary Wells
by Rosemary Wells