THE SUBMISSION by Amy Waldman
Kirkus Star

THE SUBMISSION

KIRKUS REVIEW

The selection of a Muslim architect for a 9/11 memorial stirs a media circus in Waldman’s poised and commanding debut novel.

The jury assembled to select a design for a memorial in Manhattan represented every important interest group: a 9/11 widow, an art critic, a governor’s representative and other major stakeholders. They considered blind submissions before arriving at a garden-themed design. The one contingency they didn’t plan for was that the winner would be a Muslim, Mohammad Khan. Though he’s not especially religious and his bona fides as an architect are impeccable, Khan still becomes a target for anti-Islam firebrands, and even his defenders are left wringing their hands. Waldman skillfully presents the perspectives of a handful of major characters, including Claire, a 9/11 widow; Sean, a pugnacious victims’ activist who lost his brother in the attacks; and Mohammad, who vacillates between gloomy isolation and outspoken defiance at attempts to reject or tweak his design. Waldman shrewdly, subtly reveals the class and race divisions that spark arguments about who “owns” the design; it’s no accident that wealthy Claire played a leading role on the jury while Asma, a working-class Bangladeshi woman who lost her husband in the attacks as well, is all but unheard. Waldman, a former New York Times reporter, discusses 9/11 victims, memorial gardens and Muslim-American life, but her keenest observations are of the media. She has a canny understanding of how a New York Post front page can stoke right-wing rage, or how a New York Times article can muddy the waters. There’s a slight cartoonishness to her characterizations of cub reporters and radio hosts, but overall this is a remarkably assured portrait of how a populace grows maddened and confused when ideology trumps empathy.

A stellar debut. Waldman’s book reflects a much-needed understanding of American paranoia in the post-9/11 world.

Pub Date: Aug. 9th, 2011
ISBN: 978-0-374-27156-5
Page count: 352pp
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2011




2011 BEST OF FICTION: THE TOP 25:

FictionLAST MAN IN TOWER by Aravind Adiga
by Aravind Adiga
FictionUNTIL THE DAWN'S LIGHT by Aharon Appelfeld
by Aharon Appelfeld
FictionTHE SENSE OF AN ENDING by Julian Barnes
by Julian Barnes
FictionOTHER PEOPLE'S MONEY by Justin Cartwright
by Justin Cartwright

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

FictionAMERICAN DERVISH by Ayad Akhtar
by Ayad Akhtar
FictionTHE RELUCTANT FUNDAMENTALIST by Mohsin Hamid
by Mohsin Hamid
NonfictionBATTLE FOR GROUND ZERO by Elizabeth Greenspan
by Elizabeth Greenspan