Email this review


Fuentes rarely sets an easy task for himself in his novels; usually, in fact, he takes on some sociological, political, or philosophical enormity. And this time the challenge is especially daunting, with disquisitions on a broad range of ideas: the Old World held hostage by the New; French garden architecture; sensuality; the fascination of Latin American intellectuals with all things French; the power of ancient pre-Columbian objects; the art of narration ("a desperate attempt to reestablish analogy without sacrificing differentiation"); and memory's interaction with the past ("We imagine that the instant belongs to us. The past forces us to understand that there is no true time unless it is shared"). Oddly, however, when Fuentes packs all this imposing intellectual material into a narrative bag here, the bag seems not overstuffed (as you would expect) but softly collapsed over empty space. The framework: Fuentes as narrator is having lunch with Branly, an 83-year-old Parisian count. And Branly tells a book-length story about: his acquaintance with Heredia, a Mexican anthropologist; his invitation to Heredia and young son Victor to stay with him a while in Paris (Heredia's wife and other son were killed in a plane crash); his participation in a game of Victor's--which involves phoning any other Victor Heredia listed in the phone book; and the nightmarish sequence of events that goes on in the home of this other Victor Heredia (duplication, ghosts, homosexual reunion, cruelty, history-through-humiliation). As you may have already sensed, this plot is terribly hard to follow--especially since Fuentes combines a slow-moving Jamesian style with the elegant surrealism of late Bunuel. And there's a distracting self-consciousness throughout. So--though patient readers may find themselves gradually appreciating the meditative yet tough-minded approach here, the mode of ruminant distillation--this novel is one of Fuentes' less successful experiments: anemic when it attempts to be limpid and (even more so than usual with Fuentes) without the controlled craft to match its ambition.
Pub Date: March 8th, 1982
ISBN: 1564783456
Page count: 244pp
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1st, 1982

CARLOS FUENTES, 1928-2012:

NonfictionTHE BURIED MIRROR by Carlos Fuentes
by Carlos Fuentes
FictionTHE ORANGE TREE by Carlos Fuentes
by Carlos Fuentes
FictionTHE CRYSTAL FRONTIER by Carlos Fuentes
by Carlos Fuentes
NonfictionA NEW TIME FOR MEXICO by Carlos Fuentes
by Carlos Fuentes


NonfictionTHE GREAT LATIN AMERICAN NOVEL by Carlos Fuentes
by Carlos Fuentes
FictionDESTINY AND DESIRE by Carlos Fuentes
by Carlos Fuentes
FictionHAPPY FAMILIES by Carlos Fuentes
by Carlos Fuentes