WHAT WE TAKE FOR TRUTH by Deborah Nedelman
Kirkus Star


Email this review


A novel spins a story of hard choices and secrets, set in beautiful but ironically named Prosperity, Washington, in 1991. 

Although the logging town of Prosperity at one time more than lived up to its name, that era is fading fast, thanks to a new environmental awareness. It is tree-huggers against loggers, protecting the forest habitat versus feeding one’s family. Caught in the middle of this is Grace “Parrot” Tillman, whose mother died when she was a child. Her father died some years later so the only family she has left is Aunt Jane, a bitter woman with no love for Prosperity or its loggers. Grace feels a strong pull to flee Prosperity, but fate has a way of intervening. Mill owner Jackson Dyer dies and leaves her an old cabin in his will. His wife tells Grace: “He wanted you to have your own place. Some place in Prosperity you could always call home and come back to if you ever left.” Later comes a bombshell: a huge secret involving Grace and her family that somehow the whole town managed to keep from her. Grace is devastated, then furious. The rest of the tale amounts to slow closure. While this is Nedelman’s (co-author: Still Sexy After All These Years?, 2006, etc.) first novel, she has two nonfiction books and a raft of short stories to her credit. She also has a Ph.D. in clinical psychology and her practice inspired much of her intriguing new work. What could have been a straightforward polemic about tree-huggers and loggers quickly becomes much more subtle and nuanced than that. It is a late coming-of-age tale about Grace, a wonderfully drawn character, a young woman who doesn’t want to take sides, and the author lets her skirt that argument. Having taken over Aunt Jane’s cafe, the Hoot Owl—the endangered bird at the crux of this ecological battle—Grace just wants to survive and maybe bring the town together. Nedelman’s writing is adept with some surprising descriptions (“The town glowed like a bearded hermit stepping from his annual bath”). The tale’s only villain is a man named Nathan Roberge, who’s connected to Grace’s family; the other characters are desperate people but not evil. A key question hovers over the engrossing story: When push comes to shove, will everyone shove together?

An impressive environmental tale with an engaging heroine from a talented new novelist.

Pub Date: June 15th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-950437-18-4
Page count: 314pp
Publisher: Adelaide Books
Program: Kirkus Indie
Review Posted Online: