Email this review


In Lee’s second novel after the bestselling The Piano Teacher (2009), Hong Kong sets the stage for stories of expatriation, cultural divide, and, most strikingly, the varying ways in which grief causes isolation, as seen through three connected women.

“You can survive a tragedy, given time,” thinks Mercy, a mid-20s Korean-American Columbia graduate who moved to Hong Kong for a fresh start after years of being unlucky in life. Unfortunately, a change in scenery doesn’t cause much of a change in her happiness; desperate for a job, she agrees to accompany a wealthy American couple and their three children on a trip to Korea, where a terrible “incident” involving one of the children—that's what everyone chooses to call it, hardly capable of being direct—occurs and she is deemed responsible. The novel begins nearly a year later, a year during which grief has settled in Mercy’s core, as well as in Margaret Reade’s, the beautiful family matriarch who hired Mercy. As Mercy “wonders when she’s supposed to start her life again, when she is allowed,” Margaret is dealing with similar feelings—“she cannot live. She cannot not live”—and yet the two women are completely isolated from one another and from their community of expats, whose beautiful families and lavish lifestyles now seem unreal, untouchable. Lee’s portrayal of Margaret’s grief is the most powerful; the quiet, daily suffering of a mother who’s experienced unspeakable loss is profound: “she is aware of a black hole that she must avoid at all costs. She is teetering at the edge of it, peering down.” The women’s isolation is mirrored in Hong Kong’s expat culture, which Lee describes in full-bodied detail, a culture painted in rich, tropical color—but only on the surface. A third woman, Hilary, is also connected to this story, but less intensely, and her experience with grief and isolation—while relatable—pales in comparison to Margaret’s, as well as to Mercy’s level of disassociation. An unfortunate side effect of unraveling tragedy is that these characters are lost in reflection, and so there's not much present action and the narrative is often lacking immediacy. Some plot threads beg for more conflict, others are simply forgotten—this book gets lost in thought.

A richly detailed novel that rubs away at the luster of expat life and examines how the bonds of motherhood or, really, womanhood, can call back even those who are furthest adrift. 

Pub Date: Jan. 12th, 2016
ISBN: 978-0-525-42947-0
Page count: 336pp
Publisher: Viking
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 15th, 2015


by Kevin Kwan
FictionNECESSARY ERRORS by Caleb Crain
by Caleb Crain