THE ONLY STORY by Julian Barnes
Kirkus Star

THE ONLY STORY

Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A May-September romance devolves into dysfunction and regret.

Much like Barnes’ 2011 novel, The Sense of an Ending, this one involves a man looking back at a youthful error in judgment and considering its consequences. Paul, the narrator, recalls being 19 and falling for 48-year-old Susan, who's in a loveless, sexless, and abusive marriage. Cocksure about their relationship in spite of others’ judgments—Paul’s parents and Susan’s husband are righteously indignant, and the duo are kicked out of the tennis club where they began their affair—Paul decides to move in with Susan to pursue “exactly the relationship of which my parents would most disapprove.” The thrill of independence is short-lived, though, as Susan’s nascent alcoholism intensifies; the first half of the book mentions Susan’s drinking habit, but as if to mirror Paul’s youthful ignorance, Barnes doesn’t overtly signal how deep she’s sunk until she’s practically beyond help. Barnes also shifts the narrative voice across the novel to underscore Paul’s callowness: The novel opens in first person, turns to second as if to shift blame upon the reader, then closes in a bereft, distant third. Barnes’ characterizations of both Paul and Susan are detailed and robust, though given the narrative structure, Susan remains a bit of a cipher. What prompted her to drink? What kept her from pushing back against her husband? Most critically, what drew her to Paul? Paul, though, is mainly concerned with what made their romance distinct from the usual romantic clichés. In other words, he’s narcissistic, and his rhetoric, in first person or not, often takes on a needy, pleading tone (“sometimes, first love cauterizes the heart”; “tough love is also tough on the lover.”) But that’s by Barnes’ design, and it’s consistently clear that Paul was in love, just tragically ill-equipped to manage it.

A somber but well-conceived character study suffused with themes of loss and self-delusion.

Pub Date: April 17th, 2018
ISBN: 978-0-525-52121-1
Page count: 254pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15th, 2018




MORE BY JULIAN BARNES

FictionTHE NOISE OF TIME by Julian Barnes
by Julian Barnes
NonfictionKEEPING AN EYE OPEN by Julian Barnes
by Julian Barnes
FictionPULSE by Julian Barnes
by Julian Barnes

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

FictionPARADISE by A.L. Kennedy
by A.L. Kennedy
FictionCHARMING BILLY by Alice McDermott
by Alice McDermott
FictionTHE GIRL ON THE TRAIN by Paula Hawkins
by Paula Hawkins