CUT FROM THE SAME CLOTH by Robert D. San Souci

CUT FROM THE SAME CLOTH

American Women of Myth, Legend, and Tall Tale
adapted by & illustrated by
Age Range: 8 & up
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

 A frequent author retells old stories and, in effect, fashions new ones to fill a void that--he says in his preface--he deplores. Arranged geographically from northeast to west (including Alaska and Hawaii), these 15 tales of clever, strong- willed, or larger-than-life women represent several cultures- -Anglo-, Native-, African-, and Mexican-American. Introductory remarks discuss locale or culture or note parallels in world folklore. The results are entertaining and often tellable. Yet San Souci alters stories to suit his purpose: e.g., the woman he calls ``Old Sally Cato'' is unnamed in his Missouri source, while the male giant she kills was ``Bally Sally Cato''; even the African-American connection seems tenuous. Compared to one cited source, ``Annie Christmas'' is cleaned up almost beyond recognition. Neither is the subtitle quite accurate: two protagonists are sisters under the fur. And while the animal tales enhance ethnicity (``Sister Fox...'' is the only Mexican American tale), they have a mean-spirited tone not found in the others. Detailed notes give clues to how much San Souci has embellished, rather than ``collected,'' here; Pinkney's handsome b&w scratchboard illustrations and a spacious layout give the book a distinguished look. As they stand, the stories are useful; but it would be more honest to explain the rationale for the substantial revisions. Brief introduction by Jane Yolen; map; bibliography. (Folklore. 8+)

Pub Date: April 21st, 1993
ISBN: 0-399-21987-0
Page count: 160pp
Publisher: Philomel
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 1st, 1993




MORE BY ROBERT D. SAN SOUCI

ChildrenHAUNTED HOUSES by Robert D. San Souci
by Robert D. San Souci
ChildrenAS LUCK WOULD HAVE IT by Robert D. San Souci
by Robert D. San Souci
ChildrenSISTER TRICKSTERS by Robert D. San Souci
by Robert D. San Souci

MORE BY BRIAN PINKNEY

ChildrenPUPPY TRUCK by Brian Pinkney
by Brian Pinkney
ChildrenHIP-HOP LOLLIPOP by Susan McElroy Montanari
by Susan McElroy Montanari
ChildrenMARTIN RISING by Andrea Davis Pinkney
by Andrea Davis Pinkney