ANNIE'S PROMISE by Sonia Levitin

ANNIE'S PROMISE

Age Range: 11 - 14
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

 In a third book about the Platts, who fled Germany in Journey to America (1970) and built a new life in L.A. in Silver Days (1989), youngest daughter Annie, 13, is attending a Quaker camp in WW II's last weeks. Still weak from an appendectomy, Annie blossoms at camp, easily making friends (especially with Tallahassee, an African-American in her cabin); enjoying a crush on a junior counselor; becoming a favorite of the director; and starting a camp newspaper. Troubles echoing the world outside don't loom large, but, still, after Annie plays a cruel prank on an obnoxious, racist camper, her conscience troubles her. Home again, Annie finds her family in disarray: Ruth's soldier, traumatized by seeing the death camps, jilts her; rebelling at Papa's close supervision, Lisa moves out; and when Tallahassee visits, Papa--already in turmoil because of his daughters' new independence--reveals his own racism. The conclusion--Annie confronts Papa (``You are just like the Nazis. This is why there are wars!''), then runs away, back to camp, where she realizes her own limitations before coming home for a reconciliation--is overtidy (Annie does have a lot of epiphanies at once); but, still, the lessons are valuable and the end is satisfyingly dramatic. Not as strong as its predecessors, but Platt family friends won't want to miss it. (Fiction. 11-14)

Pub Date: April 30th, 1993
ISBN: 0-689-31752-2
Page count: 192pp
Publisher: Atheneum
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 1993




MORE BY SONIA LEVITIN

ChildrenJUNK MAN’S DAUGHTER by Sonia Levitin
by Sonia Levitin
ChildrenSTRANGE RELATIONS by Sonia Levitin
by Sonia Levitin
ChildrenTHE GOODNESS GENE by Sonia Levitin
by Sonia Levitin